Whitewashing the Black Panthers


The truth is the opposite of this propaganda piece. The Panthers were psychopathic Stalinists. The article starts by describing how they tortured their own members.

Whitewashing the Black Panthers - Michael Moynihan http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/07/25/whitewashing-the-black-panthers.html

reply

It's a great article and Moynihan is one of the best active journalists. He doesn't brook any bull$hit and takes great delight in tipping sacred cows. I never miss one of his pieces.

reply

This 1971 NEW YORKER MAGAZINE article is vital reading to get the full Black Panther story:

http://www.edwardjayepstein.com/archived/panthers.htm

It also shows there's nothing new under the sun... (recent * cough cough * news stories).

reply

You do realise the FBI were instrumental in infiltrating the organisation and causing infighting, and that was likely the main reason for much of the violence which later ensued.

Most of what the real original organisation was aimed at, was stopping white cops from much of the needless hostile police actions against black citizens on the streets where they lived.

The rest was largely grand standing publicity.

reply

Except in every one of those examples that is not the case.

You are an example of this problem: As writer Steve Wasserman recently noted in The Nation, the Panthers’ many hagiographers have often “refused to acknowledge the party’s crimes and misdemeanors, preferring to attribute its demise almost entirely to the machinations of others.”

reply

Man, black women looked just like black men back then! Thank god the afro went out of style and hair straightening came into play.

reply

It's hard to tell if OP watched the film. The doc I just watched did not depict a flawless Panthers party, or sugar coat their failings.

As jimthing1 said:

You do realise the FBI were instrumental in infiltrating the organisation and causing infighting, and that was likely the main reason for much of the violence which later ensued.


I feel the doc did a good job showing the way the FBI infiltrated the party and very successfully exploited divisions. Rightfully, the doc shows how these divisions led to the demise of the party, infighting, and violence, but didn't use COINTELPRO as a way to excuse the actions of it's members.

reply

The documentary tells the truth, history backs that up. Nobody believes your BS article from a far right wing hate site.

Victory is Mine!!!

reply

History backs up that the Panthers were a de facto racist hate group who murdered many innocent people, preached genocide and oppression and idolized Mao tse Tung. Your Regressive Left revisionism doesn't change that.

reply

Maoists, actually:

reply

Good documentary. Where are all the stand-up guys today?

(Sitting at their computers, making comments about black women's hairstyles.)

I know the doc is somewhat slanted. But it gives a good picture of how things were then. Interesting times. Look at this country today, it's a disgrace, we are the laughing stock of the world with this orangeass moron DT about to take office. God help us.

reply