MovieChat Forums > Pendekar Tongkat Emas (2014) Discussion > The most expensive Indonesian movie flop...

The most expensive Indonesian movie flop?


It costs 25+ billion IDR but it's really not that good. The sceneries are awesome, the sets are beautifully made. But the story is so underdeveloped, so are the characters, and the script is just so bad. I was so enthusiastic to watch the movie for its casts, crews, producer, trailer, etc. But I bet soon enough, negative reviews and meme jokes will flood the Internet and withdraw people to go and watch this movie. Do you think this film will be the biggest flop in Indonesian movie industry?

reply

Seburuk itukah? Aku belum nonton sih, trailernya belum cukup memikat. Dari review yang beredar di internet sepertinya kekuatan film ini adalah pada visualnya semata.

Btw, The Raid 2 biayanya lebih besar lagi dan gak balik modal juga.

------
People only want to hear what they want to hear

reply

Ngomongin Raid 2? Mereka balik modal dari penjualan DVD dan BluRay, karena orang bule actually BELI BluRay nggak nyari di ITC.

reply

about that DVD sales:
Raid 1 :http://www.the-numbers.com/movie/Serbuan-maut#tab=summary
Raid 2 :http://www.the-numbers.com/movie/Serbuan-maut-2-Berandal#tab=summary

------
People only want to hear what they want to hear

reply

The Raid has been out since 2011, whilst Berandal just came out last year. I live in Canada and even now, some people are just discovering The Raid Redemption. Give it time.

reply

Did Gending Sriwijaya also flopped btw? Since both from the same genre

But I do agree with your assessment. I feel SO disappointed by that movie. The pace is slow, banyak long STILL takes yg super nggak penting,

I think Mira Lesmana should've sticked to making kids' movies, that's her expertise!! (Angin is a kid and he's perfect!!! I love him!! Dara smiled only once in the WHOLE movie, the rest of it she's just frown/ looking gloom)

Please stay away from making something like this!! You don't understanddddddddddd what to expect from an action movie!!

What this movie lacks are:

1. Fast pace (example: Fast and Furious)
2. Blood & sense of reality (example: The Raid)
3. Really, no need to blow up the scenery because it's just a support!!
4. Good script, not awkward lines
5. I hv nothing against time lapse but - [SPOILER] to see the kid's alredy maybe 8 years old I was like, lolwut how many years have passed during Dara's training, really???
6. [SPOILER] the "redemption" Elang spoke about at the end of the movie - what kind of redemption was that?? Is that he's going to banished and journey all around Indonesia to help people in need? Well it's not like he's been living an exactly steady life anyway, he's a chief of a nomad/ exiled tribe for f's sake!
7. [SPOILER] Why cast Reza in this?? I really didn't get the feel of a villain from him throughout the movie. His expression was bland, except for when [SPOILER AGAIN] Gerhana died and THEN he showed a different (mad) expression.
8. In general, this is just NOT a well thought movie. It's like it's a game that's not yet beta-ed.

Mira Lesmana, please sticks to making kids' movie, please... stay out of this genre... you have no grasp for the concept. Do you even READ books like Kho Ping Ho's Pendekar Sakti (lakon: Bu Pun Su), or Naga Sasra Sabuk Inten (lakon: Mahesa Jenar) and all others epic story with epic plot??

I want my Rp 40,000 back please.

reply

Basic rules of fast-paced fighting, or action in general, is to set the participants with as different outfit as possible.
This movie kinda ignore the rule for final fight by dressing everyone in dark, if not black, colors.
Thankfully Biru has his golden cane (and facial hair) to set him apart from Elang, but the fight between Gerhana and Dara is just too confusing I can't tell who-hits-who and they just have to fight in that dark room...

All in all, if you want some weapon fighting, I would recommend Rurouni Kenshin live-action trilogy.
There are plot stupidities I had to endure there, but at least they did what they set out to do.
They make swordfights look cool again..

-----------
Bonasera, bonasera... why so serious ?

reply