MovieChat Forums > Child Genius (2015) Discussion > Non of these kids are geniuses

Non of these kids are geniuses


They were all extremely bright but I don't see any Edison or Tesla from this group

Maybe Sam has best shot at changing world

Most of kids just robots

reply

They all are far smarter than me lol


A real genius is working on something incredible in his parents garage at 10 pm not memorizing useless facts from a given book !!!

reply

Yeah, nope -- not geniuses. Just relatively bright little robots.

reply

Oh come on now. Didn't you hear her? Claire is the "third smartest person in the world." 😁

reply

She said in the United States, but, uhhhh, yeah. Is this the crap they actually TELL these kids?!!! That this TV contest means they are *actually* the smartest children in the U.S.? Good God.

reply

A person with an IQ of 140 or higher is considered a genius. Some of these kids are in that range and some are members of Mensa. It's not fair or accurate to make judgments that none of these kids are geniuses. We are seeing a very small side of their intellect. We are not seeing how they express themselves outside of a quiz fomat. We have not read anything that they have written to see how clearly they are able to articulate their ideas. We have not seen them do real life problem solving. Adrian is clearly a genius. He has skipped several grades and at age 10 will be attending college.

reply

You don't really think that an IQ test alone (which, by the way, is not as accurate in young children -- the score tends to markedly decrease with age) is a test of true genius, do you? Do you really think all Mensa members are actually geniuses beyond the number on a test they take?

These kids are relatively bright, sure. But real genius is exceedingly rare -- someone with true genius typically changes the landscape and the conversation, thinks outside the box and creates in a different way than an average or even a very bright person. Geniuses don't just score well on standardized tests and get good grades in school. Most of us haven't met anyone who is a true genius, and I guarantee most of the kids on this show are not geniuses in the real sense of the word.

I think a lot of Adrian's accomplishments are directly attributable to his mother and how he grew up. He's smart, but he's also pushed incredibly hard. We'll see what happens to him as he grows and matures.



reply

None of the children were geniuses last season either, with the possible exception of Tanishq.

And none of the children next season will be actual true geniuses either.

That's just the nature of this show.


reply

You don't think a concerto playing 10 year old finishing High School is a genius? Geez.

reply