MovieChat Forums > The Propaganda Game (2015) Discussion > I cannot believe how much love and sympa...

I cannot believe how much love and sympathy there is for this regime.


I've always been interested in studying nK. I had an uncle who was a Korean War vet and been to ROK several times. I've toured the DMZ, been to the Freedom Bridge, and even sat at the table in the blue buildings in Panmunjom. I even participated in the ROK-US military exercises where we allegedly plan to "invade the north". I'm not one to take things at face value, so I read alot about nK. I think the situation there is pretty clear. Yet, apparently there is a fair amount of sympathy and respect for the North Koreans. Here's a few takeaways I got from this film:

The Canadian photographer he interviewed said (paraphrasing) that "it's not that the information coming from nK is wrong, it's just that there's so little of it". So, it's our fault for seizing on anything and twisting it around to fit the narrative.

Westerners should feel bad for making fun of North Korean culture, because it's not very nice.

It's completely understandable that they are armed to the teeth to defend themselves from all the hostile countries that surround them, led by the imperialist Americans.

And the crown jewel, that sums up the brainwashing. Alejandro said "I was always impressed by the idealism of communism, it's just that the people at the top were always corrupt." As if the whole system would work just fine if you plugged in the right person.

Odd, isn't it, that after 100+ years of communism in various forms and institutions, that we're still searching for a communist dictator with a heart?

Overall, I'd say the film was balanced and did include opinions from both sides. But this is not a topic that lends itself to debate. The truth seems pretty cut and dry to me.

reply

I agree. It was an interesting doc and I like that it showed both sides of the story. It's true that westerners can be arrogant and uninformed about their culture, but to deny the crimes against humanity and the fact that half the people live in poverty is crazy. Alejandro comes off as a arrogant and misled commie sympathizer.

reply

If you want to do something to bring peace and progress to North Korean ordinary people, you could start by taking your army far away from there.

The DPRK regime is one of the worst to its own people, but their army is a pile of aging rubbish unable to harm anyone outside its borders. The US instead poses a threat to the world peace with their hundreds of military bases, their "democratic" and "humanitarian" wars, and their huge nuclear arsenal.
By placing your army close to their border you are giving them legitimacy (yes, legitimacy) to build up their own army, to tell their people the country is surrounded and will only survive through struggle.

reply

There is truth in what you say, but I'd ask you what you would expect to happen
if the US actually withdrew from all its bases and got rid of their nuclear and other
weapons? It would be interesting to see a movie based on different people's ideas
of what would happen in the world over the next hundred years if that happened.

reply

> It's completely understandable that they are armed to the teeth
> to defend themselves from all the hostile countries that surround
> them, led by the imperialist Americans.

How is it completely understandable?

Given the low standards for the average person all over the world, it
is not that I respect or accept North Korea, but the majority of countries
are failing all of us around the world, have been since the dawn of history
and seem like will continue to do so, all so that some small number of
people can live without having to get dirty or work to someone else's
agenda as they would have almost everyone else do.

reply