MovieChat Forums > Strip the Cosmos (2014) Discussion > Where do they come up with this 'stuff'?

Where do they come up with this 'stuff'?


Watched a few episodes, some are very interesting, but when they strip comets and/or planets apart, how are they doing this, do they have some data collected or is this pure speculation?
I don't mind these postulations, but present it as such, do not present it like this is reality when likely only a fraction of the content of this series has any basis in science.
Tell us how you come to your conclusions if based upon data, and clearly state when you switch over to speculation informing us that we are viewing an opinion on the matter.
It may not be obvious to those without a science background that much of this speculation and I think that is a big mistake adding this unconfirmed mix into the otherwise great series, trying to teach the masses science is more than welcome, add the footnote when needed as other series had please...

reply

Equations, Data Collection, & sometimes Speculations, in that order would be my guess.

reply

I would think primarily speculation from watching this series...
I would rather see more factuality in what I view but with all the cuts in NASA I guess we will take what we can get, a statement about how it is speculation should be across bottom when it isn't factual in a science series though...

reply

I've watched a lot of Black Hole related stuff & this Episode is pretty good.

reply

It is just my degree in physics and broad field science that makes me a skeptic...

Boob toob rulez.

reply

Degree is physics cool, here's a list of what i've watched (Ignore the movies)

http://www.imdb.com/list/ls079023906/

there are also 12 lectures given by Prof: Alex Filippenko, TTC- Black Holes Explained.

reply