I like it. It adds tension in a way that typical framing wouldn't. It also pulls in more of the surroundings, putting you more into the room.
Ever since my first lessons on composition in the early '70s, it's been the same formula for film and stills; so for decades now, it's been what we all expect and think nothing off it: space in front of the dialog speaker.
It's also been typical to fill the frame with the subject's head, or if not filling the frame, use techniques to blur out the background/foreground so only the speaker is in focus.
Esmail pulls back, gives you much more of the room and keeps it mostly all in focus. I can understand how the tension could be distracting to some, but I appreciate the different perspectives.
I've always been delighted when I see something that makes me want to point to the screen and say "nobody's done THAT before!"
But of course the framing you mention is something he always does. I've never heard anyone complain before about him continuing to do it.
I also like how they've been playing with zoom lately (so from new to traditional framing in a single track), most notably in the scene with Price's 'most powerful man in the room' speech, but they've done it at least one other time since then.
Be sure to proof your posts to see if you any words out
reply
share