Ok but... (Spoiler)


the actors, the photography were great, the basic premise could have been okay, but all that stuff about messages from the other side and ghosts? What a load of mumbo jumbo.

reply

I so agree. I do love Isabelle Hupert as an actress but the great acting by the two lead actors could not salvage this movie. So bad.

reply

Isabelle Huppert, sorry for the misspelling

reply

As a vehicle for contacting the supernatural or as a story with a surprise twist, this was not that type of movie.

As a vehicle for two excellent actors to portray reunited 'exes' and how they react to a common tragedy, I thought it was engaging.

reply

Was there a message from the other side? Letters written before he died? Whatever Gerard saw, we didn't see. Imaginings based on the letters? Physical marks (stigmata?). I'm not sure what it all meant - the dead disfigured woman was pure Lynch - but it was well done. I believed Gerard about what Michael said even if Isabelle didn't.

reply