Better killer reveal? Season 2 or Scream 4

Season 2: Kieran Wilcox
This reveal was done better though him being the killer annoyed me.

Scream 4. I saw Kieran going but Jill came out of left field for me

Scream 4 by a mile.

It was probably the most unpredictable reveal of the whole franchise. It really made scream 4 a better overall movie, especially how Jill almost gets away with it and becomes so psycho.

Season 2's reveal was OK would have been so much better if Kieran was working with Eli.

Unfortunately, for me I loved Eli he was great. But Kieran wasn't enough of a surprise to me, although him being all psycho in the end was very good and I did enjoy it even if I saw it a mile away.

I think they should have made Eli a killer as well, I felt like it would have made sense. Like they could have said that the fight they had at the carnival was to reduce suspicion from them both or something. Because didn't Eli go home after that scene? I felt like it was a missed opportunity, because it would have been plausable if Eli had been Kieran's accomplice all along. I think they would have been a good double gang at the end.

I don't know, something really is missing from the scream tv season reveals. I think they should do what they did in season 2, whereby they made Zoe, Audrey, Eli and Branson suspicious and that is deliberate because they therefore could make anyone an accomplice. Kieran could definitely have been working with Zoe for example as she definitely had the brains. But then we would have missed her amazing departure which was so sad.

But yeah if they have (for the most part) such an obvious killer like that of Piper and Kieran. Change it up a bit, a 2 killer reveal works better because often one is more on the sly and ain't that obvious.

Jill

Jill, but this is unfair as the series isn't as well done as the movie franchise. If it were between season one and two. one would be the winner.

-On October 3rd He asked me what day it was "What day is it?" "It's October 3rd"-

Scream 4 was garbage. I only give the S4 reveal an edge over S2 because 2 killers was involved

Jill Roberts for sure

lol definitely Jill.
But Kieran was ok, and Amadeus' acting was pretty cool and psycho in that scene.