Most missed victim?

I wish Tatum would have lived.

Riley.

Tatum was in the film, not the show. I was referring to victims in the TV series.

You really got me with this one. I'm torn between Jake, Will, Branson, and Kieran. I don't know who to miss more. I mean.....

Jake - He had potential with all the scheming and blackmailing. Plus he seemed to be a bit psycho but he survived the season just to be killed immediately in the next season. I miss his potential. He could have been a good pick for the killer. He was also a fun character despite the inconsistent writing with his character. He was entertaining though.

Will - Another character kinda wasted. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed his death but the character could have lasted longer and became very suspicious towards the end of the season to setup a scene between him, Kieran, and Emma similar to the scene with Emma not knowing to trust Eli or Kieran and Sidney with Randy or Stu and Sidney with Mickey or Derek. The Will/Kieran feud could have been explored further and Will could have lasted through season 2 until the finale. In the season 2 reveal, Emma would have the gun pointed at Will and Kieran, not knowing who to trust. Kieran would ultimately gain Emma's trust. Then Emma would be nervously shaking and aiming the gun at Will while Will tries to explain he's not the killer. Kieran would tell Emma he's got it handled and gets a hold of the gun. Kieran would then say something to Emma like "You picked the wrong guy....again!" or "You should really deal with your trust issues...Emma!!" and shoot Will in the heart, effectively killing him. Will was a pretty chillaxed character though.

Branson - Him being Piper's accomplice and the actual mastermind of the duo would have made for entertaining tv. You also gotta miss the red herring.

Kieran - There was some missed opportunity here. He was arrested just to be murdered. He should have been the "Joe Caroll" of season 3, similar to The Following.

Will, Riley, and Seth. Also, The Mayor because of Brooke

Eli may not be dead though. His character is in season 3 episodes if you look at the Season 3 cast listing on here. Not sure how he'd survive being shot so many times, but we shall see.

Riley or Zoey