some charm, but stupid plot (spoilers)
I enjoyed the acting of most of the leads. As to the plot, there were ridiculous aspects:
1. The very idea that Nick and his friends would feel obligated to fulfill the boy's monumental request to get the boy's parents back together, when dept. store Santas NEVER fulfill ANY of the thousands of requests they get, and children always manage to get over it. And how did he know whether the parents really should get back together? I didn't think so.
2.The burning-down of a business for revenge was inappropriately
thrown into the plot partly for comedy purposes with a tinkly music background and the perpetrator chuckling to himself.
3. They made alcoholism look easy to overcome--in just a few days.
4. The entire con about building the addition was totally insane-and was finally done from scratch in 6 hours to magazine-photo perfection.