MovieChat Forums > Solo: A Star Wars Story (2018) Discussion > How can Darth Maul survive being cut in ...

How can Darth Maul survive being cut in half?


And falling down that very deep shaft? If he can survive that, then Mace Windu must still be alive too.

reply

no, Mace Windu was human. Maul is not, and the dark side is the pathway to things some consider unnatural.

Sith have no afterlife, so they manipulate the Force itself, as did Plagueis when keeping people from dying and creating life.
Hatred kept Maul alive, the desire to take revenge.

reply

Mace jumped a hell of a height into the arena in AotC without breaking a sweat so it's not outside the realms of impossibility that he could survive that fall.

reply

that's nerdy but true. A trained Force user could slow his fall of course.

But I prefer people to die for good, it adds gravitas and finality to drama, or you end up with endless cartoonish clobber porn.

reply

It’s science fantasy. They can do whatever they want.

reply

No, Star Wars is and always was just Fantasy. Its Fantasy that includes technology, but it does not make it science fantasy. In order to do that, it would have to be scientific. Though unfortunatelly many movies (and books) are often mislabeled as Science fantasy and science fiction while being only fantasy and fiction.

reply

I have never heard of science fantasy. Who pulled that out of their ass?

reply

It's been around for a long time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_fantasy

reply

It's space opera. It's like a soap opera, but in SPAAAAACE...!

reply

Its stupid is what it is. Maul was cut and half and died in Phantom Menace. The Emperor is dead, he was thrown down a thermal shaft. These new movies are stupid.

reply

He's not the first Sith to survive it. In one of the games with Kyle Katarn (Dark Forces 2 maybe). One (Maw) gets cut in half during the intro fmv and comes back later. I think he had a floaty device to help him move.

reply

A question: is that Darth Maul himself, or another member of the same species?

If it's Maul himself, maybe his species is like lizards and starfish and Groot, and capable of regenerating amputated body parts. Anything is possible in sci-fi and fantasy.

reply

Quigon and Obiwan acted as if Darth Maul was dead, not as if Darth Maul had escaped. Wouldn't they have known?

reply

You know, they could have been mistaken. The Jedi were proved to be fallible in the prequel films.

reply

Going by the Clone Wars and Rebels cartoons, Obi-Wan ended up meeting Darth Maul multiple times over the years. After the events of Phantom Menace, he thought Maul was dead and was the one to eventually kill him for good on Tattoonie.

reply

I haven't seen the cartoons, but I can accept that.

I can totally see a human Padwaman making the mistake of thinking that just because he'd cut an enemy in half that guy was dead, and not using his Jedi Senses to see if the SOB could regenerate or something. Hopefully, that's not a mistake he made twice!

reply

The second time around, he watched him die, then buried him.

reply

So basically Han Solo is still alive.

reply

Not only did Maul survive his apparent death in The Phantom Menace, he appeared in Star Wars Clone Wars and Star Wars Rebels. And in Star Wars Rebel he died (again!). Obi Wan Kenobi kills Darth Maul in SW Rebels. This dude dies more often than a bad comic on stage.

reply

Obi Wan killing Maul on Tatoine happens 7-8 years after we see Maul in Solo.

reply

That would make solo about forty years older than Luke at least. Luke’s dad is a little kid in ep 1

reply

non sequitur. I repeat:

Obi Wan killing Maul on Tatoine [note: in Rebels S3, not on Nabu in Ep I] happens 7-8 years after we see Maul in Solo. The timeline is thus correct. Maul only dies once, but lives twice.

reply

Do we have any idea how long Maul's species lives?

For all we know, he could outlive Rey, if someone hadn't killed him.

reply

Okay nerds!

Who's died more times, Darth Maul, Rory on "Doctor Who", or Jean Gray of the X-Men?

Someone has to have the numbers.

reply

Kenny from South Park beats them all.

reply

The power of fan-service.

reply

You said it.

reply

You take a needle, a thread, hold still, and...

reply

It makes me wonder if people really should've raised such a big fuss over the miraculous return of Palpatine in The Rise of Skywalker when it wasn't the first time that a major Star Wars villain was brought back from the dead without any plausible explanation.

reply