MovieChat Forums > Rogue One (2016) Discussion > Why didn't the rebels send a ship down t...

Why didn't the rebels send a ship down to rescue Jyn and Cassian?


With the shield around the planet deactivated wouldn't that have been a possibility?

reply

I think the point of the story was the high amount of personal sacrifice it took to steal the blue prints of the Death Star for the Rebel Alliance to use against the Empire. I was a kid when the first Star Wars series came out and I distinctly remember the criticism of the story line that the Empire was "bad" and "evil" but showed very little back story to the struggle between it and the Rebel Alliance. Rogue One does a good job appropriating the struggle of the Rebels in the face of a growing Empire driven to dominate and lord over the many different civlizations without recourse. Besides, if they did save Jyn and Cassian then how would you explain their absence in the rest of the films?

reply

In fantasy, as in life, it's the forgotten heroes like Jyn and Cassian that make the celebrated exploits of Han and Luke possible,

And while everyone talks about Vader's scene at the end -- which is, admittedly, a highpoint in the series -- the part of the movie I remember the most is Jyn and Cassian, on the beach, embracing, as that apocalyptic plume approaches. Our penultimate glimpse of Jyn, staring down Death, tells us all we need to about who this person was, and the sacrifice she and every other member of Rogue One made for the Rebellion.

reply

I don't see how it was possible to get a ship down to the site and back out safely under those circumstances. The element of surprise was lost, Vader was there, the Rebels had already lost ships they couldn't afford to lose, the landing strip was about to vaporize, AND the Death Star was there and they were afraid to stay anywhere near it for obvious reasons. The obvious thing to do was retreat with all speed and hope no more ships were lost.

So no, there really wasn't a way to save the people on the surface.

reply

If the Rebels had "Star Trek" technology they could have beamed Jyn and Cassian aboard.

reply

And if winged pigs had flown out of Jyn's ass they could have ridden the flying pigs into orbit, but they didn't have either option.

The whole engagement was insane, there was no plan of attack and less plan for disengagement. The whole rebel fleet sort of ran in at once, and ran away again when they had the plans, I doubt anyone in the fleet gave a thought to the last survivors on the ground.

reply

I think it would have been more likely midi-chlorians flying out of Jyn's ass.

reply

If they wanted ass-midichlorians, they should have done a better job of protecting Chirrut!

reply

"ass midi-chlorians"

I bet if Lucas got wind (pun intended) of something like this he'd rue the day he sold Lucasfilm to Disney.

reply

You have NO idea what Lucas put up with - this is zip nada nothing! Not just the personal abuse from fanboys, which was really nasty around the time of the prequels, but there were things like the fan-fiction story archive that had 1200 stories about Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan getting it on.

Personally, I suspect Lucas sold out to Disney because he wanted the fandom out of his life.

reply

I never knew so many wanted Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan to make the beast with two backs.

reply

No time. As it was, I think they already stretched out the amount of time it would take for the Death Star main weapon to destroy the area.

reply