MovieChat Forums > NH10 (2015) Discussion > Hindi version of Eden Lake

Hindi version of Eden Lake


Right so if anyone wants to see the original, and far superior, version of this movie, go watch Eden Lake.
Why do these directors or writers assume that people are naive and won't instantly recognise plagiarised work. I don't have a problem if you're going to remake/take inspiration from another movie, at least acknowledge it. But no! They present it as their own work.
Common Bolloywood, for once churn out an original idea.

The worst bit about this movie is the ending. They tailored the ending to Indian audience.

reply

yes its a version of eden lake, but superbly adapted, and the ending made sense...yes it wasnt as bleak as the original still pretty good.

reply

NH10 was a much better version of Eden Lake. NH10 had a better storyline while the latter was just plain sadistic.

reply

What constitutes a copy? There are many Hollywood and world cinema films which take the basic plot from another film and change it up a bit. Heck a 2015 American film called Preservation "copied" Eden Lake, but because it added nothing original it was a boring mess. At least NH10 advanced the story and I agree that the ending of this film was more satisfying than the sadistic ending of the original

reply

LOL!

I watched Eden Lake and thoroughly enjoyed the film.

The only reason I'm even here is because not long ago I watched another good horror called Bone Tomahawk. I enjoyed the film so much I looked into the lists people made who tend to add similar films they liked.

So I come across this one in the list and notice it is Indian. I read the summary and think 'This sounds a lot like Eden Lake'

Then I had this hilarious imagination of it being similar to the film except every now and again they break out into song and dance. I imagine the group of bad guys all do a song and dance routine as they corner the poor helpless damsel in distress until Mr cool indian guy with his sunglasses and bad moustache breaks into the song. Hoozahhh!!

Sadly, I have a bit of a negative stereotype on Indian cinema. I love Indian people but their bollywood material is not for me.

However......
EENA MEENA DEEKA!!!!!! A Die Damaneeka!!!
A maka naka naka!!! A cheeka peeka peeka

reply

After many days of download, I watched Eden Lake yesterday and found as much missings as I could find:
I. Not asking for Help
2. Watched her bf beaten to death and did nothing
3. Why they still chose the same place, without securing their items, when they knew there are youngsters who are trapping them in

But those above errors are beautifully covered in NH10 and I rate it more than Eden Lake. We can also view the comments at that movie and see the criticism over there as well.

reply

wow get better internet.
they asked for help plenty of times btw

reply

It is very hard to comment. I thought the director was inspired by the 2007 movie The Right One starring Jodie Foster.
Can't say who copied who!

reply