MovieChat Forums > Gokudô daisensô (2015) Discussion > How does this compare to Ichi The Killer...

How does this compare to Ichi The Killer?


Same director, I though Ichi The Killer was pretty great in it's own unique way so I am curious about this film and how it compares

reply

They both have yakuza. That's about it.

It's nowhere near as good as Ichi.


My Top 100: http://www.imdb.com/list/ls073432147/

reply

Ichi is one of my fave movies of all time, and in the Top 2 of Miike films that I have seen (and I am up to about 30 now). while I would rate Ichi a 10 out of 10, this one got a passable grade of 7 out of 10. Amusing, silly, nicely shot, some recurring Miike themes, but not a masterpiece by any means, and definitely NOT the first Miike you should see.

reply

It's crazy as hell, that's how lol

reply

How does this compare to Ichi The Killer?


very, very badly.


reply

I saw Ichi the Killer years ago and enjoyed it but have never had the desire to see it again. The first thing i thought when the credits rolled on this was "WTF?! I have to watch that again soon,for enjoyment as much as picking up on anything I missed on the first viewing." It's just a weird gangster-horror-comedy as far as I can make out. In a good way.

reply

it's similar to ichi, but much more like dead or alive/deadly outlaw rekka.

it's funny to see such moronic hatred spewed about this film from people who clearly are unfamiliar with miike.

reply

No, the funny thing to see is people who claim they are familiar with Miike but then go ahead saying that this is totally on par with movies like Ichi the Killer, Dead or Alive, Visitor Q etc...

This one had some funny scenes but was quite a mess overall. To me, it's around 5/10 territory.

reply

Exactly, it's more like Full Metal Yakuza and his earlier Yakuza flicks. People were expecting Ichi too much and felt burned when it didn't follow suit.


No, the funny thing to see is people who claim they are familiar with Miike but then go ahead saying that this is totally on par with movies like Ichi the Killer, Dead or Alive, Visitor Q etc...


How many people are saying that though? Glancing over the boards it's full of hate, not to mention it only has a 5.4 on here and a 61% on RT. You certainly can't call this overrated.

Personally I thought it was a blast and absolutely something you would certainly see in his mid 90's to mid 2000's output in larger budget form.

reply