MovieChat Forums > Mommy (2014) Discussion > Are french movies always this good ?

Are french movies always this good ?


I´m not american or british but I´ve always thought that nothing good could come from a cinema thats not from both this country. I watched 3 french movies in my life beeing Mommy, Heartbeats and La vie d'Adèle (wich i didnt like at all but i think is just a matter of taste) and I still have to watch Amelie wich i´m sure is great too.
I think I´m gonna let my movie prejudice aside and try movies from different countries.
If anyone have a suggestion of another great french movie, please leave it here for me

reply

I´m not american or british but I´ve always thought that nothing good could come from a cinema thats not from both this country.

That's a really silly way of thinking. Some of the best movies ever are from Europe or Asia.

Try Incendies (2010). It's one of the best movies from Quebec (which Mommy is also from).

CG GORE IS THE WORST THING THAT HAS EVER HAPPENED TO THE HORROR GENRE!

reply

try these amazing foreign movies:

La vita è bella

old boy(by Chan-wook Park)

amores perros

Sen to Chihiro no Kamikakushi

Hable con ella

Sur mes lèvres




here is my list: http://www.imdb.com/list/ls076724931/


reply

Thanks for the replies and i'm definitely gonna check those recommendations

Sen to Chihiro no Kamikakushi

Thats a classic. I love japanese animation and Hayao Miyazaki, I watched almost everything he´s done

reply

This isn't a french movie, lol.

reply

well it's a French Canadian movie

reply

Sorry but French movies and French-Canadian movies are WAY different.

reply

Who are you responding to? This IS a french canadian movie.. it's from Quebec. If you were responding to my post, I don't understand your point?

reply

Who are you responding to? This IS a french canadian movie.. it's from Quebec. If you were responding to my post, I don't understand your point?

You were replying "well it's a French Canadian movie" as if the "French" here made it less Canadian and somewhat French. It doesn't. French Canadian is Canadian.

Believe me there is very little in common between anything French and French Canadian. Even the language actually 

For every lie I unlearn I learn something new - Ani Difranco

reply

[deleted]

As for the language difference between Quebec French and France French, that would be like saying American English has very little in common with British English. Different accents,



as a matter of fact you do teach english and your are talking about how differently frenchs and canadians speak english. this is not the point at all. French canadian is not french. and no you can't compare uk english to Us english. you can do that for swiss french or belgium french, but french canadian is totally different. hollywood movies are dubbed for french canadian and "true " french differently, while belgium or swiss use the 'true' (that's the official name use : true french vs canadian french )french version. Canadian french is a strange language ( I'm not even referring to the accent), they use lots of english and worse they use literal translation of english words or expression in french hence this movie for instance is subtitled in "true french" as french speaker anywhere in the world wouldn't understand most of it.( btw I'm french..)

reply

No, the person said it is a French Canadian movie as in not a French movie from France.

reply

French Canadian is a meaningless term. There are some people who speak French in most parts of Canada. A majority of Quebecers feel identity wise more Quebec than "Canadian".

This is QUEBEC cinema, different from "French Canadian" cinema, coming from anywhere in Canada... very different cultural environment, and also different from French old-world cinema. Quebec cinema is as distinct as Quebec culture, from other cultural concepts.

Insisting on "French" creates the same linguistic problems that using "English" to describe citizens of the USA. To get beyond this linguistic conundrum... the preferred language is anglophone and francophone.

Additionally, the expression "French Canada" or "French Canadian" is kinda out of fashion. Reminiscent of a time before official bilingualism in Canada.

Happy movie watching.

***So I've seen 4 movies/wk in theatre for a 1/4 century, call me crazy?**

reply

What ever you wish to call it, technically it's French Canadian.

reply

Wow Canucki, you have just demonstrated you are just another complete un-nuanced bloke. Keep on living in your little false and simple world.

***So I've seen 4 movies/wk in theatre for a 1/4 century, call me crazy?**

reply

Blah blah blah. Je sais la différence mais techniquement c'est simplement un film canadien en français.

reply

Si tu ne comprends pas la différence entre le cinéma québécois et le cinéma dans le reste du Canada, t'as vraiment pas assez vu de films dans ta vie.

***So I've seen 4 movies/wk in theatre for a 1/4 century, call me crazy?**

reply

Je sais le différence, mais le monde s'en fout. C'est en français et le Quéebec est dans le Canada. Canadian français.

reply

Stick to English, it suits you better.

***So I've seen 4 movies/wk in theatre for a 1/4 century, call me crazy?**

reply

[deleted]

French and Canadian French movies are different in style. So yes, it's important to be precise.

reply

America is not a country, it's a continent. And this particular movie comes from that particular continent, thus it can be called "American". It's definitely not French.

reply

I respect your opinion, because obviously, Canada is in north America, and so we should all be called Americans, but as a french canadian myself, i am NOT American. Nothing wrong with being American obviously. American,for some reason, refers to people who are from the US. I would be curious to know where it originated from.

And about this movie, it is absolutely logical to say it is an American movie, because it's from north America, etc. But it just ain't. It's a french canadian movie. It's not American, it's not French either. We have our own culture, own way to speak french - it really is a slang french, not very distinguished if you ask me - but that's who we are. I've struggled a lot about my roots, but since living abroad, i feel more proud of them. And when I see a movie like this, i can say I'm proud of being french canadian.

reply

Bien dit!

reply

well I disagree, to me an european, you are an american, like you call germans or frenchs ' europeans'. a guy from brasil is an american, a guy from french guyana, is french but still, he is an american as he lives on the american continent.
Now A guy from the US , that's an etatunien.( https://fr.wiktionary.org/wiki/%C3%89tats-Unien )
the problem comes from the fact US americans are fu*** morons and self centered, so they decided that their country represented the whole american continent.
You might disagree with this, but this is how must of us call you, from the name of your continent. And it's going to be more and more used like that as a retaliation from the fact "north americans" don't use europeans nation names but just a random 'europeans' like we are the same you know... people in most europeans country wants the death of the european unions and want to stick to their nation and feel quite offended when they are patronized by being labeled as "europeans", as if a guy from latvia or belgium have anything in common.

reply

You might disagree with this, but this is how must of us call you, from the name of your continent.


That's not true. It's far more common in French to call people from the USA "Américains" than "États-uniens," which sounds too artificial. And this is true for almost every other language. Spanish and Portuguese are about the only languages where there is some controversy about this.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

Some movies I recommend:

Caché
White Ribbon
Amour
Force Majeure
Leviathan
Dans la Maison
Cinema Paradiso
Kokuhaku
The Lives of Others
In a Better World
The Hunt
Relatos Salvajes (Wild Tales)
Nine Queens
Lore
Let the Right One In
Rust and Bone
No
Footnote

reply

Some movies I recommend:

Caché
White Ribbon
Amour
Force Majeure
Leviathan
Dans la Maison
Cinema Paradiso
Kokuhaku
The Lives of Others
In a Better World
The Hunt
Relatos Salvajes (Wild Tales)
Nine Queens
Lore
Let the Right One In
Rust and Bone
No
Footnote


excellent list, the ones I've seen it are all good films, will check the others for sure since our tastes seem close :)

I might add some more

El secreto de sus ojos
Underground
Festen
M
Goodbye Lenin
The Death of Mr Lazarescu
Rum, Lola, Run
Pan's Labyrinth
City of God
A Separation


some euro horror movies are quite cool as well, like Martyrs from France (soon to be remade in english) and REC from Spain (already remade as Quarantine)

reply

The melodramas of Lars Von Trier reminded me of Mommy, especially Breaking The Waves and Dancer in the Dark. Although they aren't French. For French, check out anything by Céline Sciamma.

reply

In the case of France specifically, historically I consider France the 2nd greatest country for films behind the US. If you liked Mommy (even though its French Canadian) I would strongly suggest you check out La Haine and Irreversible as well.

Here are 20 french films that among my favorites, you may want to start with the most recent films and work your way to the older ones.


Grand Illusion (1937)
Rules Of The Game (1939)
Children of Paradise (1945)
Bob Le Flambeur (1956)
The 400 Blows (1959)
Le Trou (1960)
Breathless (1960)
A Woman Is A Woman (1961)
Vivre Sa Vie (1962)
Jules and Jim (1962)
Au Hasard Balthazar (1966)
Le Samourai (1967)
Army of Shadows (1969)
Le Cercle Rouge (1970)
Jean de Florette / Manon of the Spring (1986)
Au Revoir Les Enfants (1987)
La Haine (1995)
The Piano Teacher (2001)
Irreversible (2002)
Perfume: The Story Of A Murderer (2006)


I've seen things you people wouldn't believe.

reply