Why the low score?


I didn't know anything about it when I started watching it. But having seen enough Dr. Who episodes, I caught on about halfway through that this was actually a sci-fi. So why the dislike? I actually liked it way more that it had a nice twist to the usual supernatural *beep* horror.

reply

When I sit down to watch a horrormovie called The Diabolical I kinda want a horrormovie with some demons, devils and such.

reply

I find the bait-and-switch to be fun. They do this a lot in Dr. Who (hate to mention it again). It starts off as a 'supernatural' thing, and turns out to be sci-fi related. Then again, you know Dr. Who is a sci-fi. I kind of agree, based on the name, I was rather in snooze mode for the first half, so missed a lot of the clues. I guess that's the drawback of the name. Still, if I had known at least that it was 'something different' I'd have enjoyed it even more. I don't think it deserves a low score though, it ain't bad. Definitely not at 5-6 level.

reply

Nothing really made much sense, the acting was so so, it wasn't scary or particulary interesting

I'm gonna refuse you an offer you can't make

reply

because overall it makes 0 sense. and the acting was pretty bad.

reply

Makes no sense? It was all pretty damn obvious by the end. If this movie is above your head, I pity you.

reply

I didn't finish this the first time I tried it. It looked not only standard, but stupid. I didn't bother rating it but my number would have been in line with its overall score... which might explain the overall score.

Then I kind of had to finish because I was watching as a social activity, and oh my, when you get to finding out it's so much more than a straightforward horror, it's so touching and so beautifully done, and so well acted, it just left me crying. I am SO GLAD I got sortakinda forced into watching the whole thing. Beautiful movie, ultimately really all about familial love, loyalty, and devotion. Wonderfully bittersweet wind-up, emotionally deep and complex.

But if you never get to that point, you might think it's a stinker. And I'm not sure how much could have been done about that while still telling the same story.

"Here, with a special report, is a midget in a bikini."

reply

I think the real failure of the movie is the editing. If they had put a few more clues early on that it wasn't just a straight up standard run-of-the-mill horror movie, people might sit through to the second half where it gets really weird and interesting. There's no enough in the first half/quarter to really make you start to wonder, earlier on what's going on.....

reply

Maybe? I feel it needed some change to make it more of a whole rather than two halves, but I'm no screenwriter! And I did like being surprised. It's a tough knot, there.

"Here, with a special report, is a midget in a bikini."

reply