MovieChat Forums > And Then There Were None (2015) Discussion > Was Maeve Dermody a last minute replacem...

Was Maeve Dermody a last minute replacement for a more famous actress?


It just seems odd. I mean, she did a good job, but she seemed to be the only "no-name" out of the main cast. I wonder who the role was offered to originally? Michelle Dockery? Billie Piper? Melissa George? Emily Beecham? Natalie Dormer?

reply

I have never heard of 3 of them besides her, Mrs Rodges, the young bloke with the car and the copper.

reply

From what she said on a short BTS interview posted on youtube Maeve Dermody was only cast days before filming started. She apparently was in Myanmar (doing what I don't know). I wouldn't think the producers would deliberately wait to the very last moment to cast the main female lead, which would suggest they had someone else lined up first. But as I have no connection or real knowledge of the industry maybe late casting is not so unusual.

reply

For the first episode, I actually thought the main actress was Keeley Hawes - she looks and speaks so much like her.

But whoever was first in line, I think Dermody was perfectly convincing in the role and it's a great kick-start to her career. No doubt we'll be seeing her in more stuff very soon. And maybe now her IMdb page will have a profile pic!

reply

I was really hoping Billie Piper would be Vera before they cast it. That being said, Maeve did a fantastic job and I look forward to seeing her in other stuff down the line.

reply

I just can't see Billie Piper and Aiden Turner together. Billie would have been great in the flashbacks, though.

reply

I'm glad they picked her, regardless. She was fab.

reply

She most certainly was

reply

She almost definitely replaced someone, seeing as Maeve was cast mere days before shooting began. Though it's possible they'd been struggling to find a suitable Vera as well.

Either way, I'm glad it worked out the way it did. She was incredible

Death Awaits (Horror forum)
http://w11.zetaboards.com/Death_Awaits/index/

reply

I just realized why she was chosen as Vera. I watched an episode of Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries and Maeve played a very similar character to Vera.

reply

For the early part I really thought she was Keeley Hawes. I have only watched the full story this afternoon and while I thought the Judge was the most likely killer due to his [I felt unlikely cure] and in truth real Judges can hardly feel neutral about some trial outcomes. His death threw me considering there was a DOCTOR to do an on site cause of death??? Not fair to the poor viewer trying to make a prediction.

My only problem was how had the Judge come by ALL the information about all of them. This must have been a sort of supernatural addition to the tale which nevertheless was enjoyable.

It did take me a little while to realise that it was not Keeley Hawes.

reply

My only problem was how had the Judge come by ALL the information about all of them. This must have been a sort of supernatural addition to the tale which nevertheless was enjoyable.


It's explained in the book, but would have really dragged if they'd included it in this.

One day the judge was speaking with a doctor who mentioned to him that there must be lots of times where people get away with murder. He mentions a recent case of his (without mentioning names) which turns out to be the Rogers case.

This conversation gives Wargrave an idea. Then he regularly starts bringing up the topic of people who get away with murder as a fishing expedition. The people brought to the island were where he got hits.

IIRC:

He was in a lounge on a boat with Vera Claythorne's drunk ex-boyfriend who told him about his former girlfriend killing Cyril so he'd get the money.

A nurse at a hospital he was in told him about a doctor killing a patient while drunk and the judge tracks that to Armstrong.

A couple of old cronies of his were talking about the war and brought up MacArthur's killing. (In the book, MacArthur was shunned by his old war buddies because they suspected what he'd done.)

The judge picked Marston out of a hat basically --- he picked him out of a bunch of similar cases. Recall, Marston's case was public as he was arrested and tried.

Blore he knew about through the courthouse grapevine.

Lombard he heard about from someone who'd recently returned from Africa.

A woman who was mad about the girl's suicide told him about Emily Brent and her maid.

So the judge spent years actively hunting this information and putting the cases together before he got his terminal diagnosis and decided to act.


reply

Thanks. I have not read the book and this really helps. I couldn't figure out the Doctor's crime at all. But my question is how did the judge arrange that no-one would come back for them at the house i.e. the boatman? Did he pay him? He must remember that no one left the island after he did not pick them up?

'For His mercies endures forever ' - Psalms

reply

IN the book Wargrave writes a confession before shooting himself and gives a lot more information. They had to cut it short for the movie because they couldn't leave Vera choking forever.

He secretly told the boatman that the "party" had been extended and that he wasn't to come back until the weekend was over. When the boatman did come, he found 10 corpses.

reply

Thanks. The adaptation had me asking a lot of questions.

'For His mercies endures forever ' - Psalms

reply

His death threw me considering there was a DOCTOR to do an on site cause of death???
However, if you noticed, the doctor didn't touch or even go near him to check to see what had happened. He should have at least taken his pulse. He just assumed the apparent hole and blood meant he'd died. I only noticed this the second time so don't feel like you're all alone here. 😉

---
"How was the war, sir?" "As any war, ma'am, a waste of good men." (Poldark)

reply

(His death threw me considering there was a DOCTOR to do an on site cause of death??? Not fair to the poor viewer trying to make a prediction.)


The Doctor claiming he's dead is a key point of the novel. When setting up this particular part of his plan he knew he needed to eliminate himself from the shrinking list of suspects to make the plan come to fruition. In the novel, Armstrong completely suspects Lombard and has no suspicion of Wargrave at all, based on Wargrave's professional standing, so he agrees to the judge's plan so they can "trap the murderer" by throwing the murderer off with Wargrave's unexpected death.

He then arranges to meet Armstrong that night so he can kill him and make Armstrong's death seem the red herring. In fact, it's Wargrave's death that is the red herring, which swallows up Armstrong.

reply

Like Alien--a bunch of well known actors, and a total unknown named Sigourney Weaver. We were supposed to think she was a red shirt.

reply