MovieChat Forums > Captain Fantastic (2016) Discussion > Be warned hostile to Christianity

Be warned hostile to Christianity


At least this film was honest when the characters state they are accepting and don't make fun of anyone, except Christians.

I wonder if this would have been OK'd if they inserted Jew, Gay or Muslim in that line?








If wanting illegals deported makes me a bigot - then wanting a rapist jailed makes you a sexist!

reply

Yep. No safe space for you here.

reply

You can only joke about the most powerful things in their category, so yes, it'd be less acceptable if they said anything else in there.

If you wanna make a joke about a sex, you joke about males, because no one will care. If you're gonna make a race joke it better be about whitey, everyone know they don't care! And then religion... it's just gotta be Chrstianity!

reply

If you wanna make a joke about a sex, you joke about males, because no one will care. If you're gonna make a race joke it better be about whitey, everyone know they don't care! And then religion... it's just gotta be Chrstianity!

Actually, jokes about Jews are far more prolific. Especially considering the fact that so many Jewish comics made lucrative careers from the popularity of belittling comic routine about Jews. Especially Jewish mothers! So, are Christians also capable of making fun of themselves? Of course they are. Just maybe not so much on this thread.

reply

That's because Christians are the majority in the USA, you stupid *beep* bitch!

Yes, I know, I'm being rude but stupidity pisses me off.

reply

I'm a christian and I didn't feel personally attacked.

I didn't at all feel like the movie was poking fun at christians as much as it was the characters making fun of christians. As viewers, we see flaws in Ben (Exemplified by his daughter falling off of the roof and stealing from the grocery store). He does a lot right but does a lot wrong too. He isn't a perfect person who is ALWAYS right. He's also not ALWAYS wrong.

It made total sense to me that he would see the bible as a fairy tale based on what we know about his and his wife's pasts. The two of them probably felt oppressed by certain christians they knew, like her parents. Let's not be totally oblivious and admit that there are some christians, definitely not all, but still some who are judgmental and look down on people who believe differently than them.

So yes, Ben and his family do make fun of christians, but the movie itself doesn't seem to say anything either way on it.

Also, I haven't read any responses here because any time God or christianity are brought up in a comment section/message board, things get pretty ugly. But, please people, try to approach stuff like this with some understanding and not get so personally attacked by things that disagree with you. also, don't attack because you disagree with someone. It makes everyone look childish.

"Am I now seeking the favor of men, or of God? Or am I striving to please men? If I were still trying to please men, I would not be a bond-servant of Christ" (Galatians 1:10)

reply

Of course not OP. You see everybody is allowed to criticise Christianity but when they cop some back you are racist, homophobe, entitled......etc

The SJW's would not go anywhere near Muslims or Jews because the blow back would ruin the film. But hey it's open season on Christians right!!!!

Hypocrites

reply

As other posters state, viewing the world view of the characters, it was an appropriate statement for their characters to make. They consider themselves to be thoughtful and willing to consider all world views. Christians are "the man" in the US when it comes to religion. All other religions in the US take a back seat by a large margin AND many christian leaders both in government (think Huckabee, Santorum) and entertainment (think TV preachers) often preach both subtly and non-subtly against other religions. I don't think they really mean ALL Christians in their statement, but only the hypocritacal leaders of organized Christianity.

To answer if it was OK to insert another religion. It's the wrong question, the question would be "Would it make sense to insert another religion given the characters?"

reply

I was (and am, for that matter) upset to hear that IMDB is shutting down these comment threats.

But reading the nasty comments here, from both sides of the argument, make me more aware of why they are doing that.

There was a time where these comment threads were more civil, and discussed films in a more rational way, even when people disagreed about some points. Those days are long gone.

reply

Ironically your signature stamp is hostile. Think your hypocrisy outweighs any need to respond.

reply