MovieChat Forums > The World Wars (2014) Discussion > Things I learned from this series

Things I learned from this series


1. Patton conquered Italy in six weeks.
2. Roosevelt (not Eisenhower) relieved Patton.
3. Patton single handedly took over Germany.
4. Hitler and Stalin spoke perfect English.
5. World War 2 tanks were magically transported into WW 1.
6. Hitler didn't shoot himself on a couch with his wife, he shot himself at his desk.
7. Stalin apparently was about 6 feet tall.


Feel free to add to list of things you have "learned".


reply

8. France was totally empty of French people in WW1. All of the fighting was between the Germans, the British, and finally the Americans who with Mac Arthur's help single handedly won WW1 by looking at a photo.

reply

MacArthur was raw he just strut through no mans land not giving a f---

reply

The Japanese army and Chinese army wear the same uniforms :P

reply

100,000,000 people died from 1914 to 1945. Didn't know that many people perished.

God has a hard on for marines because we kill everything we see. He plays his game, we play ours.

reply

I think this is one of those sarcasm threads.


reply

10. Back in those days, people aged in dog years.

reply

11: No civil wars were fought in the interwar period.

reply

12. The very first time gas warfare was ever used in war, the British already had state of the art gas masks for every soldier on the battlefield, they were totally prepared for the Germans, and weren't surprised at all when someone yelled out 'gas'.

reply

Well we can scratch this one.

They never said anything about the very first gas attack.

They dramatize the gas attack on Hitler in the fox hole.

They said "by this time Hitler was already used to gas attacks, but this time it's different.

I am just now watching and it is amazing how far off most of these posts are!

I write it off to the dumbing down of America.


reply

Really - you disagree with my first post? My post and most of the others are right on. If you think the posts here are indicative of the dumbing down of America I feel sorry for you.

reply

Well, right off the top of my head ...

13. The Bolsheviks overthrew the Czar in 1917;
14. The office of the Chancellor is a largely ceremonial position in the German government.
15. Hitler sent a million men to guard Calais from the Allied invasion;
16. Mac-Arthur was already a five star General before the rank was even created;
17. A British soldier could have shot an unarmed German soldier [Hitler] in WW I and prevented WWII even though Army records from both sides show the two men were not in the same place at the same time;

... and a million other ones that I have mercifully forgotten.


_______________________________________
Resolutely Analog In A Digital World!

reply

All in all, this treatment of the worst 30 years of human history went by like something condensed for quick reading in Reader's Digest for people with very short attention spans. It was what colleges call a "survey course." Lots of quick hit and run factoids, with almost no substance or analysis.

That aside, my biggest complaint is about some of the actors playing those famous world figures. The real Patton was tall, but the guy playing him looks about five feet eight. Even in WWI, the real Patton was a self absorbed hard-driving Type-A take-no-prisoners individual. Heaven help anyone who got in his way. He had to be forceful and driven to convince the Army - which still had mounted cavalry units - that motorized armor was the way of the future. The young Patton we saw in Ep 2 was a frat boy.

And did the young Lt. Patton really walk up to General MacArthur and speak to him without saluting? And did the Army EVER permit anyone - even officers - to have the unshaven look that's so popular today?

The young Churchill is way TOO young. It's worth noting that the real Churchill was 40 years old when the war began in 1914, well into middle-age in those times, and he had war experience in the Boer War of 1898. He was a seasoned soldier, but the young guy who played him looked like someone fresh out of college in his first job, and who, apparently, was just then learning how to smoke cigars. And not doing it very convincingly I might add.

Then on top of that, in the 15 years between his return to politics in 1920 and the mid 1930s when he really start sounding the alarms about Hitler, Churchill appears to have aged at least 50 years and gained a hundred pounds. Wow. I must say though the guy who played the older Churchill was very good, and he even looked the part. They got it right when they hired that guy.

I think the casting agents could have done a much better job of finding actors who at least resembled the people they were pretending to be. And don't get me started on the outright mistakes in the historical facts. That's another story.

I haven't even watched the third episode yet, so I dread to see how they'll rewrite WWII.


Jesus is coming. Look busy.

reply

FilioScotia......I'm surprised that you missed this fact. When Patton introduced himself to General MacArthur, his said "I am Lieutenant Patton" which, of course was absurd, because he was not a lieutenant, but rather a Lieutenant Colonel. Also, when soldiers introduce themselves while in uniform, they do not state their rank since it is already self-evident. I suppose having them both state their ranks was for the edification of the viewer....doesn't everyone know that a man with one star on his shoulder/collar is a brigadier general and someone with a silver oak leaf in the same place(s) is a Lt/Col? Worse yet...what of the actor playing Patton? Has he no idea of the role he is playing? How can he not know the rank of the person he is playing? I realize that he is just repeating the lines given to him but doesn't he actually read them before speaking?

reply

That's what got me on the portrayals of both Patton and McArthur! Patton looked unkept and undisciplined in the WW1 portrayal, which goes against everything we know about him as a historical figure and military customs. An unkept uniform and unhsaved face would have been unacceptable, especially from an officer, even in a combat scenario. I highly doubt a that version of Patton would suddenly about face and become the always flamboyant, prim, and polished demander of discipline that he was in WWII. (Queue scene from "Patton" 1970 where he chews up the officer's mess hall: "From now on anyone caught wearing a soiled uniform, with out a helmet, leggings, or tie... will be skinned!")

Then there's McArthur. Did they even mention that he was the recipient of not one, but two Medals of Honor? Why did the older McArthur look like he came from a retirement home? He looked so old a frail! Looked nothing like the middle aged brazen, bold, fit leader. How on earth did they allow him to be wearing the 5 star rank ten years before he was promoted to it and before the conception of the Pentagon Rank Pin?

reply