Anyone read the book ?


Hello everyone Just a some quick questions for anyone who's read the book.

1. What your general opinion of the book was ?

2. Also would someone be willing to give a quick outline to Rene Carpenters story in the book ?

3. what the time span of the book was ?

Thanks



reply

READ
THE
BOOK.

reply

I normally would however I'd started reading T.E. Lawrence's seven pillars of wisdom before the show appeared on my radar. Currently I'm only about a 1/20th of the way through it so theirs no way i'll finish SPoW and get through AWC before the series airs, early next year i believe, I'd also planned to re-read ADWD before GoT S5 starts but that's probably not happening either. So in turn I asked for others opinion on the book (before you say look at reviews I have already) and to clarify a couple of questions i had.

P.S. Normally I'd have the same mentality as you and tell the person to read the book so i get where your coming from.

"Lord I'm discouraged"

reply

Hateful, and all caps at that.

It was just a question, moron, and no one should EVER have to explain why a question was asked.

reply

1. The book was OK, not a classic. I'm a baby boomer, so I was fed the propaganda that the astronauts were all devoted family men. It comes as a major disillusionment to find out that they were more like Captain Kirk, and of the original Mercury 7 astronauts, John Glenn was probably the only one who wasn't cheating on his wife. As idols will, they attracted groupies whom the astronauts called "Cape cookies," Cape as in Cape Canaveral.

2. It's been so many months since I read the book, I can't help you on what it said about Rene Carpenter, other than that she deliberately wore a different style dress than the other six wives in the cover photo. But having lived through those days, I remember my shock when Mrs. Carpenter filed for divorce from her husband. It makes more sense after reading the book and learning about the astronauts' penchant for fooling around with Cape cookies.

3. The time span of the book was the 1960s.

reply

Agree that the book was OK. It seemed fairly well researched.
The best thing about it was reading the history of the times from the wives' perspectives. As has been noted, that was hardly, if ever, correctly done, especially back then.

I recommend it as a fairly interesting and fast read.

_____________________________________________
I never went in for embroidery, just results.

reply

I read it last year and loved it. There had always been hints about the men but now this book confirms how the men cheated on the wives, chased skirts, loved being idolized. These women had a kindof rough go of it all.

reply

I'm another that thought the book was okay, but rather superficial. I posted this review on my blog.


I became fascinated by the story of the astronauts' wives from the first time I saw The Right Stuff. Already living an uncertain life as the wives of test pilots who might or might not come home every night, spouses of "the Original Seven" were thrust in the limelight, fictionalized in "Life" magazines, and held their breath during each spaceflight. When HBO's Emmy Award winning miniseries From the Earth to the Moon aired, one of the twelve episodes was devoted to "The Original Wives Club," concentrating on the Mercury and Gemini astronauts' wives. So it was with anticipation that I grabbed this volume.

I needn't have bothered. Most of what is rehashed here was addressed either in The Right Stuff or "The Original Wives Club," and the whole book is written at a fourth-grade reading level worthy of "People" magazine. Koppel adopts a chatty, superficial style mixing biographical data with the pop culture references of the 1960s that might be okay for a gossip magazine, but is sadly lacking as a definitive profile of women who juggled frequently absent and often unfaithful husbands, home responsibilities, childcare, and a growing awareness of their own place in a world where opportunities besides marriage and childcare were opening daily. I did learn a few things here and there, like the fact that Trudy Cooper was a licensed pilot, but, sadly, there's not much else here for someone looking for a serious portrait of astronaut wives. Louise Shepard, Betty Grissom, etc. deserve better.

reply

Yes, I've read it. It really fills out the wives side of things that was only somewhat dealt with in From the Earth to the Moon (both the series and the book). You really have to read the book to get the whole story on Rene Carpenter, because after Mercury she had a whole career in her own right as a political advocate, writer and public personality.

The book goes on up through the Gemini and Apollo programs and then follows some of the wives after that to see how their lives turned out, especially to detail the fact that almost all the marriages ended in divorce and why.

reply

Seems as if the show should have been called the dark side of astronauts. To bad most of this series is focusing on negative behavior of the men.

reply

Well, the overwhelming experience of the wives themselves, over the life of the Mercury program, was one of absence, infidelity, crushing worry and the strain of putting up a false front for public consumption. So, it's accurate. It was a dark life, in many respects, for the wives.

Besides, they're showing John Glenn and Scott Carpenter in a positive light just as much as they're showing Deke Slayton and Al Shepard as SOB's. And they were SOB's. Read Deke Slayton's book.

reply