MovieChat Forums > Manhattan Love Story (2014) Discussion > Peter, David and Amy are siblings???!

Peter, David and Amy are siblings???!

posted 10 years ago by Toratoraben
15 replies | jump to latest

Am I the only one who thinks this is weird?

Peter looks like your typical white guy
David looks Jewish

and Amy looks Italian/Spanish

??

[–] davemerino 10 years ago

WTF? David and Amy are married. The siblings are Peter, David and Chloe. A child has 4 grandparents to draw genes from, so all dark haired sibling could have a blond sibling, if it's in the gene line. Look at Prince Harry, who is a 'ginger'. Plus Peter's papa could be the milkman, I can't rule that out until I see him.

[–] Toratoraben 10 years ago

Oh yeah chloe, not amy.

I got them confused...

but yeah the sister doesn't look like their sister

[–] tomatosauce6808 10 years ago

I agree none of them really look alike. I'm assuming at least is a half sib.

[–] lisac_2829 10 years ago

Tonight's episode cleared it up...they are half-siblings.

[–] undomiel152003-1 10 years ago

Not all siblings are alike, but, yeah, this show takes it to a new level. There is no way these three could be siblings in real life. At all.

"Light Up, Light up, as if you had a choice"

[–] lolabrw 10 years ago

Thank goodness someone cleared that up, I thought I had missed something because I couldn't grasp the sibling thing. I hate saying this but Peter and Dana are the only good cast, but they need to seriously redo the rest of the cast, they're ruining the show's potential...

[–] siu18 10 years ago

I can't believe you said that about the supporting cast. I think Chloe and the dad are just awesome. Chloe might be my favorite character on the whole show.
Also, Chloe Wepper referred to either Peter or David as her half brother on Twitter, so we might get an explanation on why they look so different as the show continues.

[–] lolabrw 10 years ago

Oh I said it.

[–] hide86 10 years ago

David looks Jewish

Exactly how does someone "look" Jewish. Do I look Catholic? Lutheran? 

[–] Karantino 10 years ago

It's not just a religion; it's also an ethnicity.

[–] napierslogs 10 years ago

They made in clear enough in the beginning that David and Peter were brothers, so I accepted that even though they don't look alike, but yeah I was thrown for a bit of a loop in the second episode when I found out Chloe was a sister. She really does look Spanish and not like either of her brothers.

But I'm actually not bothered by the casting that much. I really like Chloe and Amy. And although I'm not crazy about David, at least he's not over-the-top at all, so he's fine.

My film reviews site: www.FilmGateReviews.com

[–] tafnola 10 years ago

Watch the show. Amy is David's wife not his sister. His sister has a different mother than Peter as they have plainly explained. Finally, how exactly does one "look Jewish".

[–] TheGirl12 9 years ago

Do they have 3 different moms? I figured that Peter was the oldest with one mom and then David and Chloe had the same mom since they looked more alike but now Chloe is the youngest and David mentioned being older than Peter. It's all confusing.

[–] okayCappuccino 9 years ago

They have 3 different mothers.

David and Chloe (and the dad) are probably my favourite characters in this, the leads are cute and all, but I think the supporting cast was excellent. Too bad it was cancelled.

What fuçking language are you speaking?

[–] trudat20 9 years ago

All the kids have different Mothers. But, I think the Dad is still married to the sister's Mom

Silence is Golden and duct tape is Silver