MovieChat Forums > The Whispers (2015) Discussion > Were the 1982 children taken also?

Were the 1982 children taken also?


I know that the aliens seemed to only be taking children, but did they beam up the 1982 group of creepy, now adult children that were influenced by Drill as well--perhaps to be caretakers to the newest group of children?

reply

no they were interrupted by Thomas Harcourt

reply

I must have zoned out and missed something. I thought they left him dead on the floor and proceeded with their plans.

reply

i meant the eldest Harcourt son who was killed in Broken CHild

reply

Oops! I forgot about him and was just thinking about the father.

reply

Thomas Harcourt's brother Elliot was possessed by Drill in 1982 in the same way that Cassandra was. Thomas killed Elliot before he could send the signal, thus foiling Drill's plans. Clearly at that point the kids the 'Then-Drill' had re-programmed went into Sleeper mode.

It's too cerebral! We're trying to make a movie here, not a film!

reply

Thomas Harcourt's brother Elliot was possessed by Drill in 1982 in the same way that Cassandra was. Thomas killed Elliot before he could send the signal, thus foiling Drill's plans. Clearly at that point the kids the 'Then-Drill' had re-programmed went into Sleeper mode.


Yes, but you did not give your opinion whether the now grown up kids from 1982 were taken by the aliens along with the 2015 kids to have some horrible or wonderful fate on an alien world,or whether they were left on Earth to have horrible or wonderful fates in an unknown future.

reply

Yes, but you did not give your opinion whether the now grown up kids from 1982 were taken by the aliens along with the 2015 kids to have some horrible or wonderful fate on an alien world,or whether they were left on Earth to have horrible or wonderful fates in an unknown future.


I agree the OP's question had not been addressed, yet.

We did not see any adult taken (aside from Claire Bennigan), although adults can be taken. I'm opining adults are not desirable and wouldn't be taken. If the adults were desirable, there wouldn't be the need for the machinations with the younger children. We know the importance of children, rather than the 'untouched' adults, on planet Earth to the aliens. But we don't know the children's importance off-planet.









___________

Est modus in rebus sunt certi denique fines quos ultra citraque nequit consistere rectum Goldilocks

reply

I didn't say 'so the kids never went into space' but I said Drill's plans were foiled - if he couldn't send the signal then he couldn't call his mates in outer space. He died, the glowing blue rocks never arrived, the kids went into sleeper mode etc etc. To me, that's what has been implied in the series.



It's too cerebral! We're trying to make a movie here, not a film!

reply

I think you're misunderstanding TC's question. He/She isn't asking if the 1982 children were taken in 1982. You're right Drill died so they couldn't have been taken in 1982. He/She is asking if they were taken in the present along with the present children affected by Drill.

My answer would be no to 1982 children(now adults) being taken along with present-day Drill-influenced children. The present-day children were all instructed to different points in the Fibonacci sequence. We never saw any of 1982 children directed to similar points in the sequence. So, I think it was probably just the present-day children taken.

As a warrior and as a man, I will leave my mark upon the world! Marguilus

reply

OK in that case yes... I thought OP was asking if they were taken in 1982. Your answer would be my interpretation, that only kids were taken in present day, NOT any 1982 adults that were Drill's 1982 friends. Apologies to OP.

It's too cerebral! We're trying to make a movie here, not a film!

reply

As a couple of people have pointed out I misunderstood your post. Sincere apologies! No my belief is they didn't beam up the 1982 Drill-fiend adults in present day... I think that their intentions towards the children in whatever place they end up in is not that pleasant. I had put forward (in another post) the idea that in fact Drill was a human child originally... who better to recruit other human children? These kids are 'converted' into whatever life form or energy that Drill is.

But Scatkitties your idea is valid... we didn't see this in Ep 13 however so personally the answer would be it was only the kids that were beamed up. Series 2 could prove this theory wrong!

It's too cerebral! We're trying to make a movie here, not a film!

reply

They certainly won't be very pleased to get Claire instead of Henry, you can bet on that.

reply