MovieChat Forums > Black Widow (2021) Discussion > scar jo not using a Russian Accent

scar jo not using a Russian Accent


Did anybody think that was lazy? Since Iron Man 2? People use the cop out she is spy.
Scar Jo has been miscast since day 1 not badass enough nor could she speak with a Russian Accent

Why couldn't they get Elena Satine? She is fluent in English and Russian. In the late 90s Milla Jovovich would have been perfect

reply

Agreed - totally miscast.
She'd be better off as a Disney Princess.

reply

How can she be a miscast if she has a big butt?

reply

Game, set and Match.

reply

Shes damaged goods peaked years ago.Give it to Kat Dennings and Kelly Brook then.

reply

DUDE..REALLY?...I'M NOT ONE TO INSULT WOMEN BUT...SCARLETT STANDING NEXT TO KAT AND KELLY WOULD LOOK LIKE A MODEL STANDING NEXT TO A COUPLE OF CASHIERS FROM WALMART.🤔

reply

They still got the goods. Scar jo peaked a long time ago 🍈 🍈 🍑 🍑

reply

LMAO

reply

Black widow is a spy, it would be very sloppy of her to have a Russian accent or look Russian, how could you be spy if they can just make you like that?

So casting director has free rein to choose. The point is that black widow is a seductress, and Scarlett Johansson and Jessica Alba were the sex symbol at the time. Black widow definitely has no Latin blood in her. So Scarlett is a no-brainer.

reply

I mean James Bond is a spy too with that logic he can have an American or Swahili accent

reply

007 movies never took itself serious. Otherwise using the same alias over and over again, to the point everyone knows his name and his signature drink, that is not a spy, not a realistic one anyway, might as well put his face on commercial products.

Similarly, black widow, once she became an avenger and been on TV, she was no longer a spy, just an agent. But before that, she was trained to be a spy, like all the girls from red room.

reply

I’ve never understood why people wanted her to have a Russian accent. A proper spy should be able to speak another language and sound like a native.

reply

Exactly! What pissed me off about this was that other widows had a Russian accent. Same shit with Red Guardian. He even had a normal accent in the flashback scene.

reply

Yeah, if they were sloppy about anything, it was the other Widows/Red Guardian having accents. None of them should sound Russian while speaking English.

reply

They should all do one or the other (accent or no accent) and be consistent throughout the family.
They didn't. ScarJo got away with a lazy non-accent.

reply

It's realistic for all of them to not have an accent when speaking English, especially since we see them speaking perfect English in the beginning with no accent.

reply

Ik ln the comics shes Russian, in games and cartoons shes depicted as such. That excuse is lazy

reply

No, it’s realistic. Can you imagine someone showing up in Ohio all “Allo comrades. Aye am Natalie Rushmon. Aye am American, ya?” Kind of a good way to blow your cover if you can’t blend in.

reply

Avengers know who she has nothing to hide. Also You act like foreigners don't visit America all the time lol

reply

Once you speak a language well enough to have a solid accent, there’s no reason to start purposefully speaking the language poorly. As for Widow not caring about the accent that would directly link her directly back to her country of origin,... you don’t seem to know how spying works.

reply

I know how it works you are grasping for straws

reply

You don’t know how it works if you think blending in means not being fluent in other languages. Also, the term is “grasping AT straws”.

reply

Regardless you are still doing it. Its scar jo being lazy and unqualified for the role

reply

Damn you really dislike her… All because she doesn’t have big boobs. What a creepy weirdo.

reply

I would like female heroes to have curves like they do in the comics.

reply

I'm not. A spy should blend in and you are demanding that a spy character be obviously Russian and thus, terrible at her job.

reply

There you are defending these poor choices again

reply

You’re such a weird creepy little dude. You dislike Scarjo only because she doesn’t have big boobs anymore. What a weird, creepy and pathetic reason to dislike an actress.

reply

Shes miscast in the role to begin with but she peked years ago. Maybe in 05 she could have been the real ms marvel when she looked good not carol manvers

reply