Why the disbelief?


Everyone keeps writing that this is an unbelievable premise. They say the evil people died so how can this movie be. Are you kidding me??? These are fairy tales. You can believe that mice and birds can talk and dress people but villains can't get married and have kids, Cruella can't be black and villains can't end up in another movie after they "die"? Well, they can. It's called make believe. Disney makes it and your supposed to believe it. Suck it up and do it. It's fun

reply

if Cruella is black why cant Jafar be chinese?




Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

No reason he can't be but they didn't do that so it doesn't matter.

reply

Doc80
No reason he can't be but they didn't do that so it doesn't matter.


it does matter since the diversity is black and white and no other races or religions for that matter



No reason to have the phsypically disabled girl



Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

RIght, because middle eastern isn't a minority right, or do you think he is supposed to be white?

reply

Doc80
RIght, because middle eastern isn't a minority right, or do you think he is supposed to be white?




no but make them look there race




Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

Ok, I'm done with you, obviously too dense to listen.

reply

Doc80
Ok, I'm done with you, obviously too dense to listen.




and your proably going to be the future! Well I weep for the future

Since to find everything go to Wikiepdia RIGHT!

GOOD BYE





Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

They did have a Chinese girl. Mulan's daughter.
There's Asian.
Jafar is Arabian.
There's Middle Eastern.

This film was quite diverse. :)

reply

purplecatwarrior
They did have a Chinese girl. Mulan's daughter.
There's Asian.
Jafar is Arabian.
There's Middle Eastern.


This film was quite diverse. :)

Okay who was gay who was learning disabled

where was the white guy from Japan where was the mixed raced Chinese white guy from america?

No the film is its version of what they THINK diversity is



Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

Not LEARNING disabled, but I did see a girl in a wheel chair for a split second.

reply

aachase1988
Not LEARNING disabled, but I did see a girl in a wheel chair for a split second.



NOT the same thing



its like comparing them to the North and South Pole!






Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

And that's why I said "Not LEARNING disabled". I wasn't comparing the two.

reply

aachase1988

And that's why I said "Not LEARNING disabled". I wasn't comparing the two.



Well how do we get those in a Nick or Disney movie?




Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

The sad fact is, like the girl in the wheelchair, disabilities and other "imperfections" will be shown as token background characters. Disney's way of having characters, who aren't cookie cutter, without having them forefront for more than a few seconds.

reply

aachase1988
The sad fact is, like the girl in the wheelchair, disabilities and other "imperfections" will be shown as token background characters. Disney's way of having characters, who aren't cookie cutter, without having them forefront for more than a few seconds.




dont you think we need more diversity of that and other people being gay and more disablitites that you cant see?




Plus Carlos should have been gay

Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

The girl in the wheelchair wasn't a token background character. Its explained in the books that mermaids on land used wheelchairs.

reply

I suspected as much from American Dragon: Jake Long.

reply

Boo Boo Stewart, the guy that plays Jay, is half white (Scottish and Russian), half East Asian (Chinese, Japanese, and Korean), with a bit of Native American.

I agree they should be open about Carlo's sexuality and not try to hide it.

reply

Technically, Carlos is underage, so they can't be open about that. Talk about parents' rage.

reply

Doesn't matter he's under-age most gay people know by the time they're 8 or earlier they're gay

reply

You don't have to SAY a character is gay to make it obvious to anyone over 10 (although "anyone over 10" was clearly not the target demographic of this surprisingly shallow TV movie - the review from the parent who says his "4-year old loves" it is probably the most accurately helpful of all those posted). The Prince is played uber-gay, his two "girlfriends" notwithstanding. He was far from the only one.

reply

Really? Is that a published study or are you just guessing it?

reply

Please, go to Korea, Japan, China, India, etc, and complain about how THEIR movies aren't diverse enough, maybe not enough Inuit actors or something else equally stupid. You want diverse, make you're own diverse movie that includes every possible minority group. Stop b!tching about everyone else. They put up the money, they get to decide who's going to be in it.

reply

nitestar95
Please, go to Korea, Japan, China, India, etc, and complain about how THEIR movies aren't diverse enough, maybe not enough Inuit actors or something else equally stupid. You want diverse, make you're own diverse movie that includes every possible minority group. Stop b!tching about everyone else. They put up the money, they get to decide who's going to be in it.


oh they wont it will have to be america or great britain before it reaches india Japan and china

even then there is no diversity even though reality is otherwise






Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

Considering the original Aladdin story takes place in China in spite of the Arabian setting, Jafar being Chinese makes even more sense than any changes made on Cruella.

reply

luiz4200
Considering the original Aladdin story takes place in China in spite of the Arabian setting, Jafar being Chinese makes even more sense than any changes made on Cruella



well isnt Jafar middle eastern?


Then I would pick Ken Jeoung from the Hangover

James Hong

Jackie Chan to be the father of Boo boo character






Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

for those who shake their heads in disbelief. here is the spoiler. if you read the prequel "isle of the lost" all the villains who died in the disney movies were resurrected and sent to the isle. maleficent even has a sword scar on her chest from when the fairies sent the sword that philip threw into her. also gaston has 2 sons just like him and carlos's minions (kinda) are horace and jaspers sons. cinderella's stepmom is now a grandmother. and everyones pets are the kids of lucifer (cat), iago (parrot) and flotsam and jetsom (eels).

reply

[deleted]

i agree. but thats what they did. maybe they thought death was an easy way out of paying for being evil. i have no idea.

reply

As I remember:

Aladdin (1992) is set in a Arabian Nights setting corresponding roughly to sometime between about maybe 700 and 1800 AD.

Snow White and the seven Dwarfs (1937) is set in a fairy tale medieval age about roughly 1000 to 1500 AD.

Sleeping Beauty (1959) is set in the 14th century (1301-1400 AD).

Cruella De Vil is supposed to be a more or less contemporary character in the novel The Hundred and One Dalmatians (1956) and the movies One Hundred and One Dalmatians (1961), 101 Dalmatians (1996), and 102 Dalmatians (2000).

The technology on Aurdon seems more or less contemporary in Descendants (2015).

One can assume that Jafar and the Evil Queen ("Evilina"?) flourished at the same times as Maleficent in the 14th century, but there is no strong evidence for that assumption. In any case, though Cruella might still be alive but probably too old to be dangerous, and Maleficent might be immortal, Jafar and the Evil Queen should have been dead for centuries.

Maybe Jafar and the Evil Queen should be considered evil but smart if they discovered magic to keep them alive for centuries.

Thus the villains seem to have lived over a period of six hundred or more years. If some magic can keep them from dying of old age, or bring them back to life after dying of old age, it can probably bring them back to life after being killed violently.

Thus there seems no logical problem with some of the villains having been killed off in some of their movies.

Besides, Descendants (2015) might be in an alternate universe to the main Disney versions of the stories, an alternate universe where the villains were defeated but not killed.

Or maybe the villains weren't really killed in the Disney versions.

Maybe the Evil Queen grabbed onto a ledge and the boulder missed her as it fell down the cliff.

Maybe Maleficent was only wounded because the sword missed her dragon form's vital organs. Maybe she recovered later and crawled out of her pit and flew back to her castle.





reply

As Jafar can attest thanks to Hades, death is less permanent than people tend to think.

reply

The villains who died in the first movies, you mean. Deaths that take place in sequels don't count based on Jafar's retelling on how he was taken to the isle.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]