MovieChat Forums > In the Club (2014) Discussion > Does anyone else detest Rosie?

Does anyone else detest Rosie?


I have been watching In the Club with my girlfriend more as gratuitous fascination than enjoyable drama, and of the multitude of twits in this show the character of Rosie is everything that's wrong with modern Britain.

Underage teenage, misguided single mums are a common sight in South Yorkshire, but wow do they milk how loathsome such species are in this show. Like the way Rosie sees her baby like a toy to play with, without any grasp of the responsibility she faces as a mother. She is so gormless, so incredibly stupid in the words she speaks and in her reasoning, delivered with a deadpan, moronic expression every single time.

I'm not sure if it was intended to make her character so dislikeable, but her selfish behaviour and arrogance overrides the sympathy the viewer is supposedly meant to feel for Rosie losing her Mum. And if not having her Mum around is meant to excuse her naivety and ignorance, then that is even more pandering, absurd and pitiful storytelling from the BBC.

I just hate the way she always goes "I don't WANNA do this!"... "I'm not GONNA do that!" to every bit of responsible advice she is given, especially in that monotone Yorkshire accent. Just like any delinquent brat with a sense of entitlement.

And if it was intended to cast someone with the most slappable face to match the attitude, then they pulled off a masterstroke in Hannah Midgeley! Not hard to see why she's been out of work since she played an infant Sugden in Emmerdale.

My opinion of Rosie is just another scabby benefits leech who has now spawned another who shall no doubt grow up to be the same degenerate, uneducated chav that Rosie is!

reply

Is she really worse than Jasmine

'She ain't got that haemo thing'

lol it's haemophilia u silly cow. She lied moaned complained bitched and whined all the way through and everyone cheered her on and excused her.

reply

Yes! And we saw in the last ep that Rosie is also a manipulative little twat who is going to milk this situation with Jude for all its worth.

She's given a morning after pill that she refuses to take with an excuse, invites Jude into her bed (she's some piece of work whining to the dad and Kim that Jude was always complaining about not having his bed--so she manages to blame a male teen who's randy as a bull at that time of life for everything after she brought him into her bed); then we see her flushing the m.a. pills down the toilet.

She also slaps down Kim immediately on her suggestion she start taking birth control pills. So without even seeing a consultant to see what kind of birth control she might employ (which a young woman would do if she wanted to control her reproduction), she's refusing full stop by playing the cancer/mum card and stopping that line of inquiry altogether.

Rosie's seen the way to Valhalla and out of her scabby dirty council flat. And it's Jude, his middle class dad and everybody else she's been able to manipulate from the off.

So did Rosie, knowing Jude at school who maybe told Rosie and others at school that his mom's partner Kim was writing a blog about pregnancy--target Kim right up front by writing to her blog to draw the family in? Was she that savvy?

Innocent? Pull the other one. Kim and Company have fallen at every turn for Rosie's little plans.

That put a slightly different spin on the teenage-mum-of-one story. Her "arc" was interesting--we started seeing her one way at the beginning but increasingly it became apparent she's been in the driver's seat from the time she targeted Jude and led him into an alley! haha

She's not just gormless. She's taking everybody for a big ride by manipulating everybody at every turn! LOL Best case, Jude's middle class parents insist Jude marries her in a couple of years and she's set. Worst case, in a few years, she's got 3-4 kids the state is going to support for her life and theirs in a furnished council flat with all the trimmings. Either way, she's set.

That was a big reveal for ep 6. That and the big one that Roanna and Simon's dad used to have a relationship. WO!

reply

Well in all fairness Jude's folks are so wrapped up in their own issues they are blind to Rosie's manipulation.

She is probably smarter than all of them put together....for a teenager she has managed to get a nice comfy ride sorted out for herself. Not bad going.

I wouldn't have been walking on eggshells like Susie but it seems upsetting Rosie was far worse than anything else so guess they too need to reap what they sow (no pun intended)

reply

She's an interesting character. It now seems that she was keen to get out of the shabby high-rise where she had to cook frozen food for herself whilst her dad worked unsocial shifts, and saw middle-class Jude as an opportunity. Another baby will cement things, because Jude's parents and stepmother will ensure that she and the babies are ok.

At first, I thought that she was an unlucky, naive kid who'd had a bit of good fortune finally. It doesn't seem like it though!

reply