MovieChat Forums > Allegiant (2016) Discussion > YA Female Protagonist in Order

YA Female Protagonist in Order


My Opinion:

-The Hunger Games
-The Divergent Series
-The Twilight Saga

A lot of people say allegiant and the whole divergent series are worse than twilight but they aren't. Be grateful divergent series has enough action and doesn't demonstrate dull and weak moments. Just my opinion c:

Honesty shows the truth in you

reply

I found Tris insufferable. Bella was obnoxious in all her damsel antics. It's a tough call for the bottom between those two.

"The mind can be a powerful ally, or your greatest enemy."

reply

I say Herminone beats all those b***** because technically she is a young adult later in the series. The only who comes close is maybe Katniss.

reply

Tris is the only true trained soldier and fighter..Katniss could shoot with the bow, but was not a fighter..

reply

Tris is the only true trained soldier and fighter.


In the book insurgent, she couldn't even pick up a gun because of her fear .-.


Katniss could shoot with the bow, but was not a fighter..


That is practically fighting but with a weapon .-.

reply

In the book insurgent, she couldn't even pick up a gun


True. Her PTSD kept her from using a handgun, but she could use a machine gun, knife and hand-to-hand combat skills. Remember she almost killed Eric by stabbing him in the groin; and she beat up Janine (as well as her SIM likeness)

reply

Katniss was a fighter and did in fact TRAIN to be a soldier, in the book Mockingjay, Katniss trains very hard in District 13 with other rebels to become a soldier to fight the war in The Capitol

reply

Terry Pratchett's Tiffany Aching > Hermione

John Marsden's Ellie Linton (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JB1RDLVyYak&list=PLtXyhXU-VYl8EhOZxy82_tKEjbqWmVAdb&index=8&nohtml5=False) is up there as well.

reply

Hmmmm
1. Hermione
2. Katniss





3. Tris

Then light years away
4. Bella but I don't consider her a heroine personally. She shows zero qualities of a heroine for me.

reply

No, Bella was no heroine, she was a spoiled little Bit**!

reply

1. Tris, it gets to a rocky start due to simulates with Katniss but as Katniss becomes weaker, Tris ends up as number one.

2. Katniss, starts out strong but lets herself down in Mockingjay as Katniss is reduced to asking "Where's Peeta?"

3. Rey, she had potential but so far she's a god mode sue and a sympathy sue.

4. Hermione, an annoying self-insert character who is never allowed to be wrong. Most of her bitchiness is toned down in the films but she still attacks Ron for being the victim of sexual harassment.

5. Bella, she was designed with zero personality.

reply

Katniss becomes weaker, Tris ends up as number one.


The book Mockingjay reflects war as brutal and vicious, if tris was in that book, surely she would be the same as katniss.

starts out strong but lets herself down in Mockingjay as Katniss is reduced to asking "Where's Peeta"


I kind of agree with you at that point but she regains herself during the battle of the capitol and the mutts scene.

Most of her bitchiness is toned down in the films but she still attacks Ron for being the victim of sexual harassment.


You just made my day lmao

she was designed with zero personality.


.-. A bit too far with the words, I find her character in Breaking Dawn Part 2 way more satisfying than in the other 4 films since she shows bravery and strength but yeah..

Honesty shows the truth in you


reply

The book Mockingjay reflects war as brutal and vicious, if tris was in that book, surely she would be the same as katniss.


So you blame the writing?

I consider the writing to be the character.

I kind of agree with you at that point but she regains herself during the battle of the capitol and the mutts scene.


Most of the problems were in Part 1 of Mockingjay but the romance was really bad.

.-. A bit too far with the words, I find her character in Breaking Dawn Part 2 way more satisfying than in the other 4 films since she shows bravery and strength but yeah..


The problem is it's the fifth film. Really she should ideally reach that level during the first film.

edit: actually after seeing Rey, no she shouldn't reach that level in the first film.

In fact, Twilight should have been a trilogy.

New Moon was just stuff that should have been included in the first film and Breaking Dawn should have been just one film. They should also just have put in more jokes in the earlier films like they did with Breaking Dawn Part 2.

They also should have had the final battle scene actually happen.

And not turn Jacob into a child molester, I mean what was wrong with pairing him with one of the vampires?

reply

Most of the problems were in Part 1 of Mockingjay but the romance was really bad.


True but the romance wasn't that bad, probably not the best but not that terrible. I liked both of the parts, really intriguing c:

Breaking Dawn should have been just one film


I could've been but that book had more than 700 pages so it had to be split into two parts and it got a reason unlike Mockingjay.

They also should have had the final battle scene actually happen


That moment when I was in the cinemas and I saw the battle, I was really excited but hen I realised it was just a vision, I was appalled :(

reply

I could've been but that book had more than 700 pages so it had to be split into two parts and it got a reason unlike Mockingjay.


But they didn't need to include everything in the book.

reply

It's been years since I read Potter, when did Ron get sexually harassed? I prefer book Hermione over film Hermione (Watson is godawful).

GoonGirl for Hire

reply

Girls were using love potions on him. And Hermione attacks him for being a victim.

reply

Based on the movies:

Tris
Hermione
Katniss





Bella.


Tris is a fighter in action and spirit and she sees what others don't. Katniss is like a walking personification of passive aggressive. I wanted to like her, but she doesn't plan or deal well with her emotions. Can't relate to her and Bella's depressive bubble.

reply

I agree with you but I think Hermione and Katniss are both great characters tbh.

reply

I am surprised no one has mentioned Rey, the 19-year-old protagonist of the new Star Wars films. If you ask me, she beats every other YA heroine I've seen. And yes, I have seen Hermione.

Daisy Ridley is bae.

reply

If you ask me, she beats every other YA heroine I've seen


No she doesn't.

Daisy Ridley is bae


Ikr <3

reply