Doesn't seem fair


It doesn't seem fair to not eliminate anyone tonight. Those dresses were as bad anything that has been eliminated. Favoritism toward Anya?

I guess it's like looking at clouds. You see one thing and I see another. Peace.

reply

It was a waste of an episode. The bottom 2 were both bad, one looked like a Mummy and the other like a Kindergarten's project with those things on her chest.

reply

Totally agree with you OP. I personally think Nicholas should have gotten the boot. This was his second appearance in the bottom 2 and I haven't been all that impressed with his designs. What are the judges seeing in him that we haven't? Shan on the other hand has been in the top looks for most weeks, proving his consistency and while his bandage dress wasn't the best thing to walk the runway it was far and away better than that arts and crafts project Nicholas sent down the runway.

Unfortunately because the judges couldn't seem to do their jobs there is going to end up being a double elimination and I'm afraid 2 talented designers are going to pay the price. I thought the decision was easy but if anything they could have done like PR Runway and made the designers rework their designs.

reply

These judges are terrible when coming up with the one to be sent home. Already they've had Anya pick for them and now not sending anyone home. And I have a feeling that Tim Gunn had them send Isabelle home last week due to him almost having to drag her out of the work room.

reply

I'm still not over how his first design looked EXACTLY like an oversized t-shirt, and the mentors absolutely adored it. I'm shocked he didn't go home last night!

reply

EXACTLY!!! I couldn't believe it! I'm to the point when I hate something on PR, I say "the judges will LOVE it" and they always do lol.

I like Shan, hated his design, but he should have stayed, the other guy should have went home.

reply

I've always been that way but I know I have no taste.

I judge them by whether or not I would laugh if I actually saw someone walking down the street wearing one of the outfits.

reply

I agree that it wasn't fair.

A Fact Of Life...
After Monday and Tuesday, even the calendar says W T F....

reply

The whole thing felt staged so that Nick is sure to be eliminated first. Anya's team isn't strong and her mentoring isn't working. She shouldn't be rewarded by getting to keep her team members. I thought the whole point of the show was to eliminate the mentors until one team was left standing.

reply