SPOILER! Don't open unless seen.
Did Tyler shoot Kyle????
That's where I thought the plot was going also, but the movie never really explained Kyle's death.
shareRight? I thought and took it as he got shot in the arm fire from the bad guys. I didn't think for once that Tyler shot him. Because Kyle did after all, run to Max's side. Plus, wouldn't the marines know if he was shot by one of his own men due to their weapons and numbers on the guns??
So after the film- my mom said to me that's what happened and I told her no I didn't think so. But I think Tyler didn't feel too bad- after all, he knew that Kyle would rat him out about the weapons.
My take after watching the movie was this:
Max was running ahead when the explosion went off. Kyle ran forward for Max not knowing if he survived the suicide bomber. Then the bullets started flying from both sides. When Kyle ran forward towards Max, Tyler should have either pulled him back or started shooting to cover Kyle. However, he didn't do either and jumped and hid behind the wall because things would be easier for him if Kyle was dead. The other men in their company had to yell for Tyler to get back in the fight. By the time he stepped out from behind the wall, the fight was already over. This is also why he lied to the Dad regarding Max being responsible for Kyle's death because really Tyler was responsible for not pulling him back or covering him in the fire fight. It's plausible though that he shot him before moving behind the wall to take cover. The movie never really fully explains it.
After the dust cleared you see Max jumping and very agitated. Kyle grabs the dog and holds on the him to calm him down. You then see Tyler has his gun aimed at Kyle and the dog but lowers it when all the other Marines group around them. Then the scene ends. I was under the impression that Kyle was fine and something happened to him off screen. But I could be wrong.
shareAlso, Max tried to attack Tyler then and another Marine had to calm him. I still think it was friendly fire.
shareWe saw Kyle threatening to expose Tyler's weapons theft. Tyler had to shoot him. We don't know how long after the explosion this took place. Maybe in the heat of a bitter argument, maybe Tyler's partner shot him, if he had one? He likely just shot him, because he felt he had to, to avoid prison.
shareIt is not established if Tyler was guilty of premeditated murder ( he really did not want to hurt Justin so I doubt it. But Criminally Negligent Homicide he was guilty of, plus weapons sales, kidnapping assault and quite a few other crimes. However, Max made sure he was sleeping with the fish.
share