Disgustingly staged


Longtime Alaskan and former AKRR employee, and this show is ridiculously staged. From the phony "emergencies" at the homesteads along the railbelt, to the fake "near misses of wildlife and trains" that feature stock footage from decade old AKRR promo video, all capped off by the silly quick cuts and overly dramatic music that just makes you roll your eyes. The "emergencies" they deal with are just routine, day to day stuff that AKRR staff don't even raise an eyebrow at. Ice overhangs? Big deal... couple shots and down she comes. Frozen switch? Happens all the time, which is why there are multiple sensors at each switch that phone home so HQ can get a repair crew up there long before a train gets close.

Sadly, something that was barely touched on in the "ice dagger" episode is just how bad things are financially for AKRR. Moving coal, petroleum, and heavy equipment for both industries has been the lifeblood for the company since the track was laid, but recent overreach by the Feds and EPA have all but shut down coal mining and refinery operations up North. because of this, AKRR has lost millions this year alone, and has had to lay off countless more employees like Hugh. Not mentioned in that segment, btw, was the ridiculously high severance and retirement package all those employees received. His family is going to be just fine until he finds something else. Many of the other employees who were laid off recently, who don't have Hugh's seniority and saved up benefits, however, have been struggling.

reply

we can see that it is staged because it is a TV show made for entertainment. I like the show. I have always wanted to live up there for some reason. I am sick and tired of the corruption,waste fraud and abuse from the state and federal government in the Boston area. the Irish gangsters were using the FBI to help in their business by letting them know who was informing and they were arresting the competition. the governor is a complete boob who waste money like it is going out of style and has no clue whatsoever how to actually do the job he was elected to. also he is an affirmative action hire who was elected because he was black. he was fired at 2 big companies for his incompetence and later sued them claiming it was because of the color of his skin and not his total lack of competence. we've have been stuck with him for 8 years and the media covers(protects) him. they are not telling the voters just how much of a mess he has made of things or just how much he has put us in the hole. word is that it about 45 billion ! every single department that he over sees has it's own scandal going on. there are around 75 people dead as a direct result of his incompetence. we had the compounding scandal where the state never checked on this drug company that mixed it's own drugs and sold them around the world. they were not even suppose to be doing that. they were suppose to be filling individual prescriptions but with no state oversight they decided they could make millions by being a manufacturing company. we have children who are dead because of the social service agency is mismanaged so badly. we have a woman who also is black who was being paid a huge salary to run the early education system. it ended up just being a no show job and she did not even live in massachusetts and was working in another job in the western part of the state. it goes on and on and every time you turn around they are raising taxes or fees to cover for all the mistakes they made and all the money they blew on friends and family. and we have been stuck with this because of the corrupt system that keeps these people in power.
this is why I always wanted to move up there. and this show just gives me some sneak peaks at it.

reply

You are SO right. Stock footage varies the number of locomotives, TYPE of locomotive and cab number from shot to shot. Number and kind of rolling stock and even the load vary in the show. Faked emergencies are almost always on a siding... Gee... and crafted blockages! come on!

reply

I was a conductor. When it was cold we always has fires in the yards where the switches were or putting Hexane on the switches or just putting pots filled with Karosene. There are Trackman and all they do is make sure the switches are ok. I can't imagine in a place like Alaska were it is cold most of the time they have no equipment for that. Heck I worked for the LIRR and the switches never got frozen and believe me it gets cold on Long Island in the winter. I like the show though. It is entertaining, and I like to see how the people live off the grid. You know that they have got to make up drama for people to watch.

reply

I like the show too. I'm entertained by it. Isn't that what tv is for? I don't understand why people feel the need to nitpick and analyze things down to the smallest detail.

I'm fascinated by Alaska and enjoy Life Below Zero and The Last Frontier as well. I know they are all staged to a certain degree. Don't care one bit.

reply

I liked the part when they lost a wheel on the shunting-vehicle because there were no bolts on it. Strangely enough though, that wheel was being filmed as it fell off...

Yeah this show is *beep* horrible, I can't believe this is the Discovery Channel
format nowdays, they used to have good programs...


Light travels faster than sound,
that's why people seem bright,
until you hear them.

reply