MovieChat Forums > Still Alice (2015) Discussion > Forgot to show the next 16 years in a de...

Forgot to show the next 16 years in a dementia facility


Pretty good movie, and Moore did a great job (as usual).

But... I wish they'd showed her being moved into a dementia facility (as is pretty much inevitable), then showed her as an old woman finally succumbing to pneumonia after spending the next 16 years as a crying, baby-food-eating nappy-poo-generator.

This movie only covered the first few years of what would have been likely to have been a 15-25 year tragedy.

reply

When you lost that much, it doesn't matter anymore.

reply

The final word of the film is "love" which should embody the spirit one has if they have someone in a home for that long. I know I do.

Your day could be worse 

reply

the next 16 years after the ending. Do you really believe she will live another 16 years after? you must be joking. Have you watched the movie too and did you see how fast her Alzheimer progressed? You don't know much about early on-set Alzheimer, do you?

reply

Early-onset progresses much faster. My friend was diagnosed at 54 and died at 56.

And when you tell a story, have a point. It makes it so much more interesting for the listener.

reply

That's messed up and a bit scary, sorry.

reply

I think she was 50. The opening scene was her 50th birthday party, which I assume was meant to let us know the character's age at the time it began.

reply

That's so sad.

wab-3 = Dengal/vans johnson/b profane/SNL fan/Film/Carmudgen - who else?

reply

I think that the writers "spared us" from having to watch the horrid follow-up to Alice's disease level...the writers spared us from watching an already sad movie become much much sadder. I mean we pretty much know what's going to happen to ALICE. We know...
Sad sad movie.
~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

reply

As another poster said, early-onset is different. A woman I know was diagnosed in her late 40s and died at 50. They were told her life expectancy would probably be ten years or less.

reply

Correct. She may have had, at best, 16 months to live when we see her at the end of the film.

reply

The movie is told from Alice's point of view. The movie ended with her youngest daughter making an effort to still connect with her mother. Perhaps the movie ended with the last time Alice was able to be herself, the last time she was to communicate. With Alice unable to connect to the outside world, and tell her story, the movie had to end.

reply

That what I thought Mmitchell. Kristen Stewart reciting Harper Pitt's closing monologue from Angels in America and Alice comprehension was sort of the perfect ending and, (at least I though), represented Alice's last connection with another human being.

reply

Exactly. For me it's all in the title - the film ended while she was literally still Alice. Shortly after scene she stopped being herself forever.

reply

Life expectancy for early onset alzheimers is about 10 years at best
So in sixteen years she'd be long dead.
Brain detorization happens much quicker than in older patients

reply

I think I would much rather have early onset Alzheimer's than develop it as an elderly person. At least early onset moves quickly.

reply

Why the *beep* do you see that as a positive?

reply

Why do you not? You'd prefer to have your family go through that for a lot longer?

reply