MovieChat Forums > Logan (2017) Discussion > What was happening with Logan?

What was happening with Logan?


Why was he dying ?

reply

Yes.

reply

Yes. The metal inside him was poisoning him.

reply

The metal that been inside him since like years ? Why now

reply

No clue. I think it's a lot to do with his mental state. It was a marvellous movie.

reply

Because even he wasn't immortal. His healing factor slowed his aging by a great deal, but didn't stop it. As he got older, the healing factor got weaker and less capable of regenerating damage. When he was younger, it was more or less capable of instantly regenerating damage from the poisoning caused by his adamantium skeleton. Once he got old enough, and the healing factor weakened enough, it couldn't fully keep up, and at some point, the damage from the poison began to build up affected his overall health to reduce his healing factor's capability still further -- a downward spiral of sorts.

reply

I think his body was constantly trying to fight whatever that scientist released that killed so many mutants.
I think his healing factor was over-taxed.

reply

So the scientist poisoned all the mutants? I was trying to figure what happened to everyone...
I think part of Logan's problem was that he was getting old; after centuries of fighting, he'd certainly worn out, and his healing was probably just fading due to overuse over all those years.

reply

I agree he was getting old but the scientist released some type of poison that targeted mutants only. It is why there are a few mutants left and why no new mutants are being born. The poison was released and distributed innocuously in food and drink products like cereals. Logan was also affected and like the previous poster said, was constantly fighting the poison he unknowingly consumes 24/7. If he leaves the city, drinks from a fresh stream and hunts and farms his own food, he could probably eventually be released from those poisonous toxins in his body. But as long as he continues to drink and eat the poisons that are hidden daily, his body will focus on eliminating them 24/7 and is probably over-taxed.

reply

Okay. I didn't quite follow the whole mutant-poisoning thing. Thanks for pointing that out.

reply

The audio in my threatre was really hard to follow tbh. Maybe it's the film itself that had bad audio which is why many missed it when the scientist was explaining it.

reply

Maybe. That's why I always use subtitles at home, even though I'm not hard of hearing.

reply

Me too, I always turn on subtitles unless I've seen the movie a couple of times and no longer need it.

reply

Thanks for that explanation, vicky. I missed that part - the scientist was talking too fast for me.

So I guess Logan was trying to earn enough money to move out with Charles to some countryside? Very sad they couldn't realize that dream.

reply

It's a very bitter sweet end for both Wolverine and Xavier. Watching this, I never really saw Logan and Charles relationship as a son-father relationship, but more like a father-son relationship, with Charles being the aging son of Logan's. The last of everyone he ever cared about dying.

reply

[deleted]

This article subsection covers a lot of the history and complexities of his adamantium poisoning.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolverine_(character)#Powers_and_abilities

As the text starts, "His primary mutant power is an accelerated healing process". The skeletal structure enhancements were more than just genetic mutation, so it seems to me that he stands apart from the rest of the X-Men in that regard.

This installment (the film) in his history adds pus coming from his claw exit points and wounds that are no longer healing / regenerating as quickly as before, helping to define what is 'end of life' normalcy for him.

Though nobody can expect future owners of the X-Men franchise to stick to the story, given how many times it's changed already.

reply

Given Disney now owns Marvel I'm afraid most future movies will tend to be more Disneyfied... Probably only a matter of time until they have rainbows flowing out of the backsides of all the super heroes.

reply

Disney is doing right by Star Wars--as evidenced by Rogue One

reply

I agree.

reply

Only decent, recent, Star Wars movie.

reply

just a theory but a very good one
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viOpP6P_PrQ

reply

The scientist who was behind the efforts to catch the girl also supported efforts to put gene therapy in mainstream foods that suppress the mutant X gene. That is why mutants are losing their powers and new mutants are not being born. Any who eats commercial food or drinks commercial beverages was exposed to gene therapy designed to suppress the mutant X gene.

Their goal was to get rid of all the mutants except the ones they could control in their experiments (like the kids, or the bad wolverine from X-24).

Logan was dying because his mutant powers were being suppressed by this gene therapy hidden in food (his healing power was being suppressed) and combined with poisoning from his adamantium skeleton, it was making him very sick and near death. Normally his healing factor would heal his adamantium poisoning before it became a problem, but without his healing factor the poisoning just got worse and worse.

reply

That's one of the best explanations I've seen. Thanks!

reply

But the new kid mutants also eat regular (poisoned) foods and they're okay. When they were still in the lab facility, the scientists can gave them clean food, but in Logan's hut she ate regular packaged corn flakes with milk.

So that means the poison is no longer distributed (because virtually no mutants left anymore anyway) or the new mutants are unaffected by the poison?

reply

The poison takes time to start working. The kids had been eating clean food until they escaped, and I think they only escaped a short period before the film started.

reply

Was there a movie I missed, or where was this explained?

reply

Why is everyone mad at me for paying attention?

A scientist wanted to kill all the mutants, except ones he controlled which he wanted to use for warfare purposes. So he put gene therapy in foods and drinks to suppress the mutant X gene. This caused all the mutants to lose their powers and for new mutants to not be born.

He also created a bunch of children under the X-23 project to create a bunch of mutants he could use as soldiers. However the children didn't want to be soldiers and rebelled. So he created a new project, X-24. He used that project to clone mutants but to also make them subservient and obedient. That is what bad wolverine was, a clone who was a mental slave.

reply

Didn't Xavier blame himself for the mutants losing their powers? I remember that.


I'm trying to go for an engaging, funny youtube channel so, if you have the time, take a look. Hope you enjoy what you see. Thanks in advance. A review of the movie here-https://youtu.be/sgSF7ho3cc4

reply

Didn't Xavier blame himself for the mutants losing their powers? I remember that.

Nah, he was blaming himself for The Westchester Incident.

reply

Who said anyone was mad? I'm genuinely curious, because I don't remember anything about his healing factor not working because of the food.

reply

Whatever it was, I'm positive he felt it was a longtime coming.

reply