MovieChat Forums > Risen (2016) Discussion > Is this a good movie?

Is this a good movie?


I am a person who loves movies, and i love historical onces, or that has a historical theme that takes place in a historical time, yeah what ever u wanna call it,

So i am wondering if anyone could tell me if this is an ok movie to see for a historical fan?

reply

It's dull and lifeless. Honestly, sleep inducing and doesn't even capture the desert it's supposed to represent well at all. It will test your patience, not your faith

reply

lol..somewhat of a good description...worth waiting to watch on dvd/blu ray/digitially..whatever... imo as far as movies go you can do worse..but it's not great either

reply

"Dull and lifeless????" There wasn't a single scene in that movie that could fall under that classification. The story and characters were vivid and interesting. My patience was never tested and neither was yours since you clearly didn't see the movie.
That's fine if you aren't interested in the movie or what it represents, however it's truly unacceptable that you create posts based on a lie.

reply

lol lie?
Maybe look up the word 'opinion'...

I'm the product of a fu7ked up generation. I can't even seem to find a sunset to walk off into

reply

Opinion?? Wrong!! It's a known fact that the anti-Christian crowd come out in force on IMDB to vote 1 star for any movie with a Christian theme.

I don't understand why they feel so threatened by Christianity. They like to cite the Crusades of 1000 years ago, however, what they fail to grasp is that if it wasn't for rulers like Richard the Lion Heart, who drove out the invading Muslim armies, all of Europe would have fallen under Islam.

The early mathematicians of the Middle East gave us the 10 base number system, algebra, among other accomplishments, but with the rise of Islam all of that was considered anti-Islam and it was abolished. The Middle East became scientifically dead. This is what would have occurred in Europe if Islam would have become the ruling majority. We would have none of the technological advancements we do today, and our lives would resemble that of the people who currently live in Saudi Arabia. Where people are executed for simple crimes, women are treated worse than cattle, and homosexuals are put to death.

Please Google The Barbary Pirates for another lesson on Islam. Those Muslims raped, pillaged, killed, and sold well over a million people into slavery during their reign.

Any other false premises you have please feel free to share them.

reply

drew dropping truth bombs
I'm convinced to watch it by your historical aptitude.

reply

drew dropping truth bombs
I'm convinced to watch it by your historical aptitude.

It was... a very solid 3. He said, Lifeless and dull? Come now man, art thou made of stone? ^_^

reply

Yep. I was amazed to see it had over a six on here. Considering the atheist/agnostic/etc crowd is hell-bent to one-star anything even vaguely Christian that number is pretty impressive.

Oh, why are they threatened? Because somewhere inside every last one of them with an IQ over 80 knows they are wrong.

reply

here wasn't a single scene in that movie that could fall under that classification. The story and characters were vivid and interesting. My patience was never tested and neither was yours since you clearly didn't see the movie.

I agree, this was a great film, the people who find did dull are dull themselves. They are expecting to see some swords fights and blood but Risen was not that kind of film. It was actually refreshing to watch a film that wasn't your typical dumb Hollywood studio movie like "Gladiator". Joseph Fiennes did a great job and he is really underrated as an actor.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I am a Christian and I love historical movies, that being said this movie is one of the most boring biblical movies I have ever seen. Words can not describe just how boring this movie is, I didn't expect much but was hoping for something at least on par with what I might see on The History Channel and I was extremely disappointed.

reply

I disagree with the other posters. I thought it was excellently made historical film, as far as costuming, conceptualization and little historical details.

"The thing I hate about an argument is that it always interrupts a discussion."
G. K. Chesterton

reply

It was an amazing film. You're not going to get high level CGI. It's a drama. Low key drama slow paced...Even the miracles are low key relying on dialogue and camera only. The story makes the movie. Just a wonderful film. The message is peace so except for the necessary death scenes, it glides along to convey the transformation of an unbeliever to a believer. But, it is not about some powerful moment...more of a low key understanding....while sticking to Biblical history.

That's what makes the message and movie beautiful...

Galena

*Free speech opinion w/ pseudonym internet moniker w/o malice for debate and discussion🌈

reply

Galena,

I totally agree with you! As you watch the movie, you go on the journey with the characters. It is as if you are walking along with them- feeling the emotions they felt at the time. It renews your faith and makes your realize how loved we are by our creator. Great movie!

Lena

reply

For a historical fan, yes, it's worth a watch.

It's nowhere near the caliber of "Gladiator," but it is engaging and does have a relatively realistic view of the period.

reply

"For a historical fan, yes, it's worth a watch.

It's nowhere near the caliber of "Gladiator," but it is engaging and does have a relatively realistic view of the period."


Nowhere near the caliber of Gladiator for a historical fan? Because Gladiator was actually completely fabricated and the makers made no attempt to stick with historical events, especially in regards to the emperors depicted.

reply

I meant in terms of film making quality -- Gladiator was fabricated, but it was extremely well done, massive in its scope, with gorgeous costume design and an awesome script.

reply

Gladiator was actually completely fabricated and the makers made no attempt to stick with historical events

Fabricated, yes, like all movies based on history. But there's quite a bit of historicity to the film:

(***SPOILERS***) Marcus Aurelius allowed his unworthy son, Commodus, to become Emperor, knowing his incompetence BUT it is believed Aurelius wanted Claudius Pompeianus to succeed him as Caesar in preference to Commodus but was turned down, just as Maximus turned him down in the film. The fictional character of Maximus was partially based on Pompeianus, who had a similar career to Maximus' and personality traits as well, as documented by Herodian. In fact, Pompeianus married Marcus Aurelius' daughter, Lucilla, following the death of Lucius Verus. Maximus was also an amalgam of historical people like Narcissus (which was the protagonist's name in the first draft and Commodus' real-life killer), Spartacus (who, of course, led a significant slave revolt), Cincinnatus (a farmer who saved Rome from invasion, then resigned his six-month ruler-ship after 15 days), and Marcus Nonius Macrinus (a faithful general and friend of Marcus Aurelius). As for Commodus' entering the arena at the end and taking on a mighty (albeit wounded) gladiator and dying, Commodus was known to engage in show combat in the Colosseum, but he was actually strangled by the wrestler Narcissus in his bath, not killed in the arena, and he ruled for a dozen plus years, unlike the relatively short time shown in the movie.

Say what you will about these (common) cinematic deviations, but the movie does inspire you to look-up the historical facts.

My 150 (or so) favorite movies:
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls070122364/

reply

Fabricated, yes, like all movies based on history. But there's quite a bit of historicity to the film

You are correct partially about the history aspect of it but "Gladiator" was a remake of Anthony Mann's 1964 "The fall of the Roman Empire":
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0058085/?ref_=nv_sr_2
with Stephen Boyd and Sophia Loren. That film was a box office failure, even though it's not entirely a bad film. Gladiator took on the same story except they changed the character of general "Livius" and made him into fictional " Maximus" and added the Gladiator spun as an arc into the story, like they did in Ben-Hur who was sent to galees to create the revenge element and a show down between him and Commodus. I didn't care for the movie "Gladiator", it had some good scenes and moments but it was very overrated.
Yes movies do inspire us to look-up the historical facts, but Hollywood some how is also rewriting history and some actually believe it.

reply

I didn't care for the movie "Gladiator", it had some good scenes and moments but it was very overrated.


Yeah, I think it's overrated as well, but like it a little more than you did.


My 150 (or so) favorite movies:
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls070122364/

reply

It's nowhere near the caliber of "Gladiator,

"Gladiator"?.Lol...That is a very bad comparison and I guess that's what most people were expecting to see and they were disappointed because it wasn't like "Gladiator".

reply

This was an excellent movie. A new different perspective on story of Christ. Well acted and true story telling, not relying on special effects.

reply

It was excellent. The writing, acting, directing, cinematography were all top-notch. It's a thinking person's film about the resurrection of Christ, told through the eyes of a Roman soldier. IMO, this is Joseph Fiennes best performance in years! His powerful performance made the movie.

reply

Yes! The wife and I went to the 7:35 showing last night and it was very good. The reviewer who replied claiming that it was "dull and lifeless" obviously hasn't seen the movie. The acting is first rate, as is the cinematography, etc.

I would be the first to admit if this were a B quality film, and it simply isn't. I was waiting for that "one" unbelievable actor (like the girlfriend of the main character in "God's Not Dead") and there weren't any.

I usually watch action movies (Kingsman,etc) or comedies (Spy,etc), but I can say with 100% sincerity that this was truly a very good movie.

BTW, please ignore the people who give it 1 star because it's a Christian film. Those people truly need a hobby, dog, or girlfriend to get them through their miserable existence.

reply

Yes. Artistic license is taken. It is not all biblically accurate. It shows characters, events, and how one skeptic was changed. Interesting through a Roman military commander's eyes.

Can you fly this plane?
Surely u cant be serious
I am serious,and dont call me Shirley

reply