War of the Worlds Ripoff


This was just a cheap ripoff of War of the Worlds, down to killing the Martians off with a virus. If H.G. Wells was still alive he would sued the *beep* out of these no talent writers.

reply

I don't get these comments. It's not a ripoff in large measure because it's in a totally different style. Read it instead as a documentary about the same (fake) historical event.

BTW, we still don't have a single really good War of the Worlds movie. The '53 one was a staple of my childhood, but is really not very good all things considered.

reply

It's not a rip off, it's an homage

reply

It IS a homage, not a rip off. How many million times has "Cinderella" been told, in a million different settings? An American version, a modern version, a "reverse gender" version, etc.

reply

OH grow up. He would have loved it.

This was not a rip off but rather a great retelling, sort of like paean to Wells.


They who give up liberty to
obtain a temporary safety deserve
neither liberty or safety

reply

Absolutely! remember, this is the man who also later wrote THE WAR IN THE AIR and THE LAND IRONCLADS - if he had had the foresight of WW1-technology aeroplanes and tanks when he wrote WOTW in 1897 he would definately have used them. And the video has exactly the right *feel* in every sense. Much more so than any pre-existing cinema effort.

This is unquestionably the best by far version if WOTW I have ever seen, although I would still dearly wish to see a version which was actually true to the time and place of the book. I'd say that if Wells were going to apalled by 'no talent writers' and rubbish adaptations he would have saved his ire for the other versions presently existing, especially the mawkish George Pal and the (really horrible) Spielberg version.

reply

Wow - you really better not watch Jeff Wayne's TWOTW - you'd hate that. Total rip off!!

reply

JJk50...get a life, seriously.

reply

He would have no grounds to sue. The War of the Worlds is in the public domain.

reply