MovieChat Forums > La sapienza (2014) Discussion > From the review by A.O. Scott in The New...

From the review by A.O. Scott in The New York Times for March 20, 2015


Review: In Eugène Green’s ‘La Sapienza,’ a Search of Ideals of Civilization

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/20/movies/review-in-eugene-greens-la-sa pienza-a-search-of-ideals-of-civilization.html

"The characters in “La Sapienza,” Eugène Green’s new film, tend to look directly into the camera when they speak, to speak clearly and grammatically, and to refrain from interrupting one another. The rhythm of the editing is similarly deliberate: The camera looks at one person, then another, and patiently surveys a landscape or the interior of an old and magnificent building. This graceful, unhurried style, with its blend of austerity and artifice and its roots in classical French theatrical traditions, is Mr. Green’s signature. American by birth and ardently European by residence and vocation, he elevates formal decorum to a moral principle. “La Sapienza,” quiet and conversational as it seems, is a passionate defense of — and perhaps also an elegy for — an old and dignified ideal of civilization.

"And also, as such, an escape from the modern world. Though set in the present, “La Sapienza,” which takes its name from a venerable university in Rome, finds inspiration and sustenance in the past, specifically in the 17th century.

"Emotions are held in check: Voices are never raised, and passions are described from a distance rather than expressed overtly...Where, in the 21st-century West, are the sources of enlightenment and wisdom?

"Mr. Green’s response is quietly but unmistakably polemical. His conservatism — rarely articulated outright but implicit in every meticulous frame and carefully wrought sentence — is intriguing and provocative. His films amount to a protest against the vulgarity and velocity of 21st-century life...

"The movie is an unapologetically rarefied undertaking and at the same time a gracious and inviting film."

reply

Sign me up!

reply

Just saw it. Simply fantastic and a spot on review

reply

An unerring review. Simply to add that the film offers a few provocative metaphysical aspects brought out by the relationship of the "psychologist/sociologist" wife with the "old soul," adolescent girl and, that of the adult architect with the "old soul," young adult brother of the girl. The architect, dulled by cynical professional compromise, further lacks sapience because of his lack of understanding the relationship of space and light--a fascinating philosophical exploration by the film maker and, as you put it, "rarefied undertaking."[spoiler]

Sitting in a comfortable seat in a darkened theater, happily looking up at the 17th century feast for eyes architecture, the film offers the willing 21st century observer a glimpse of a world that a select, privileged few experienced in their time and place, a world that lies beyond what the most privileged could hope to experience today because they live in the wrong place--sapience and light being unaligned in our time.

reply