Kelley was more than cringeworthy
Not only was she a complete psycho she was also very clearly the least attractive girl in the whole show, that may be shallow to say but it is a shallow show so I have no problem saying it. More than anything to do with her looks the fact that she constantly looked like her hair was wet was the most irritating thing. Also her high pitched southern voice along with her freaky face made for a cringey time. Honestly, while it was entertaining to watch her slowly unravel into a complete mess it was also kind of hard to watch, I found myself wanting to tell her to shut the *beep* up at all times.
I guess she was kept on the show so long because she was 100% certifiably insane but man if I was Matt I would have told the producers to piss off and sent her home after the finger licking ordeal, or at the very least after she face raped him in that kissing game. erghh it's going to take me a while to forget how awful she was.