Am I insane???


I thought Jack was a girl and his mother just called him a boy to keep Old Nick away. He seemed to have no interest in the child and I thought it was because he thought it was a boy. I thought she was protecting her daughter from that rapist scum.

reply

Jack seemed very much like a boy to me. Made more clear once he got the haircut.

reply

She had nothing to cut his with. She had no knives or scissors. If the kidnapper gave them to her she could have used them as a weapon against him or to kill herself. When you don't cut hair it keeps growing.

reply

The only knife she had ,,,had the tip cut off of it. I saw that when she was cutting up some food.

reply

Jack was like Samson. His bravery was in his hair.

reply

Not to defend a psycho rapist abductor, but just because he's a rapist doesn't make him a pedophile. But I did find it strange he had such little interest in his own child, but again, it's hard to know how a psychopath behaves in such situations.

reply

His lack of interest in Jack is explained in the IMDB trivia based on the book. Joy had been pregnant once before, but Nick tried to help with child birth and the baby died. Joy blamed Nick and when Jack came along wouldn't let Nick help, or touch or even see Jack. Nick deferred to this because Joy had been in so much grief over the first baby.

reply

He seemed to have no interest in the child and I thought it was because he thought it was a boy.


That's an interesting theory. At the start of the movie I also assumed that the kid was a girl because of the long hair.

reply

I thought the same as the OP for a while, And after the story started unfolding a bit i said to my self obviously he helped her delivering the child so of course he knew he was a boy.

English is not my native language.
Want to know who did 911? visit http://www.911missinglinks.com/

reply