MovieChat Forums > David Brent: Life on the Road (2017) Discussion > Yes, anything Office/Brent needs Merchan...

Yes, anything Office/Brent needs Merchant's eye...or goggles


I second the earlier commenters: Gervais is funny, but The Office was more than just funny. Merchant brings the je ne sais quoi that, IMVHO, might well make or break any such project. The bar is set very, very high and so to go it alone would be a fool's errand.

Here's hoping the A-Team is on it.

That's racist.

reply

I honestly don't think they talk anymore.

reply

I think you're right.

It'll be interesting to see how the film turns out without Merchant's influence.

reply

Did you read that on a internet forum? As far as I know Merchant decided to do Hello Ladies on his own as he didn't believe Gervais could relate to it so Gervais started working on something different and now their time frames are out of whack. Nothing more than that as far as I or anyone else not directly involved knows.

reply

@GarryMMM ...their time frames are out of whack.
That's a pretty weak excuse for not having Merchant working on this. We're talking about The Office here, not some stupid Flanimals book.

reply

Gervais' ego dictates that Merchant's involvement in the original Office was minimal. Whenever he's discussing the show in interviews, it's always 'I' and not 'We'.

reply

No. If you listen to the old radio shows with Karl, you'd know how Gervais sees it as a duo effort. Him being the lead actor made many think it was all him, and Merchant was salty about that. Merchant has a serious issue of narcissism that shines through and if anything, he'd be the one not wanting to work on this in fear that people won't give him credit. But this is a very different thing to The Office anyway, and is a story that probably fits Gervais more than Merchant. They work better together, though.

-

"It hurts, doesn't it? Being in pain." - Daredevil, a lawyer, 2015

reply

I've listened to all the old radio shows, and I don't think Stephen showed any narcissism. I think he was rightly upset that it was a joint effort but Ricky unapologetically got 99% of the credit, got invited to meet the queen, got invitations to special celebrity gigs, and overall treated Stephen as a forgettable sidekick.

reply

are you joking? he was playing that up for comic effect on the old shows.

reply

No, he wasn't. Stephen was genuinely upset, and Rick laughed at him.

reply

Gervais' last three projects have been Derek, Special Correspondents and David Brent movie.

Derek was an awful pile of steaming, putrid faeces.

Special Correspondents was a mediocre remake of a French film.

And now he's re-visiting The Office.

He's paddling without Merchant. Whilst Gervais clearly has something to offer, Merchant is clearly the genius behind their previous works.

reply

Derek was an awful pile of steaming, putrid faeces.
Are you kidding? Derek was brilliant. Did you watch it all?

At first I was put off by the subject matter as I didn't want to watch someone taking the piss out of the disabled but after seeing it I realised how smart, funny and heartwarming it was. I forgot I was watching Ricky Gervais after a while, as it felt like Derek was a real person. And I cried buckets over it.

reply

[deleted]

You're a piece of %&#€ who never has anything positive to say, so F off and get a life! :-)

reply

Are you kidding? Derek was brilliant.


It really, REALLY wasn't.

reply

It really, really was.

Some humour and a whole load of pathos - I found it very genuine and touching.

reply

Some humour and a whole load of pathos - I found it very genuine and touching.


It was saccharine to the worst degree. Emotionally manipulative rubbish. Karl Pilkington, basically playing himself, was the only redeeming thing about it and he left after one season.

reply

I agree with this. Derek is a virtue signalling vanity piece that tries too hard to be perfectly "heartwarming".

reply

i just came here to write the exact same thing.

couldnt find the tall man in the writing credits, so prepare for the worst.

reply

I dont want to sound like a nostalgia freak, but even if Merchant was on the case they'd never reach the comedy gold that was achieved 14 years ago, just not possible in this day and age unfortunately...

----------------------
Something like that..

reply