MovieChat Forums > Circle (2015) Discussion > QUESTION - How Far would you Have Made I...

QUESTION - How Far would you Have Made It ?


If you found yourself trapped in the same situation that those people were in were you get zapped and killed every 2 minutes until there is only 1 person left then how far do you honestly think that you yourself would go in it ?

For me, I like to think I would make it down to the Final 10 but I would probably end up getting zapped well before then. What does everyone else think ?

reply

I hope I would be morally upright enough to not vote at all.

reply

"I hope I would be morally upright enough to not vote at all."
---------------------------
You mean you would try to be like that silent guy that never voted and got down to the final 4 because of it.

reply

Nehh, I think I wouldn't want to vote but I would have been vocal.

reply

anybody else ?

reply

One thing that frustrated me in this movie was how long the *beep* lived. I was wondering who is voting for these random people when some jerkoff is making some selfish rant. If it were me I would be trying to get them killed off first, so I probably wouldn't last very long based off the choices people made in the movie.

reply

I think during these moments people may have been too distracted to actually cast a vote and the random pickings took place.

If that were the case it would actually be a good strategy to quickly and easily kill people off who might otherwise survive longer than you.

For the record though I'd like to believe I would abstain from voting if not also be vocal about the hypocrisy of it all?especially from the so called Christians in the group (I'm just highlighting them because they were the most visible/vocal religion in the movie). How can you say you love God but are also engaging in judging/killing people. That moment in particular made my blood boil the most. This movie if nothing else, showed how awful and disgusting humanity is, especially under the guise of being upright and humane.

reply

For the record though I'd like to believe I would abstain from voting if not also be vocal about the hypocrisy of it all?especially from the so called Christians in the group


For what it's worth (and I"m an atheist, for what THAT's worth), there was only one clear Christian, i.e., the pastor, and he appeared to abstain from voting until the end.

The commentary track confirms this - he voted for the lesbian without really thinking, and got her killed along with the soldier, cancer-survivor and not-a-porn-star. It ate him up, inside, which is why he stepped off his spot and died.

The other likely candidates might've been the Latina woman he comforted earlier, who also volunteered. It's also likely that the migrant worker was Christian, and he, too, volunteered.

Not that the filmmakers were trying to extol Christianity, but I think they were trying to show exactly how difficult it would be for people who profess Christianity to square their beliefs with their behavior.

reply

not too long probably. I like to think though I'm not a judge or executioner, so I wouldn't vote.

reply

I'm sitting behind an Internet wall in my Internet armchair right now, so I'd like to think that I would have been one of the volunteers.


The instrument has yet to be invented that can measure my indifference to that remark.

reply

I'm sitting behind an Internet wall in my Internet armchair right now, so I'd like to think that I would have been one of the volunteers.


Good point - I thought I'd do the same until I read your post, and now I'm not so sure I'd be that upright

I will say this: the first time I saw the film, I was pretty much with Eric right up until he did what he did. I loved that he did it, but only as a dramatic reversal.

That said, I think it's pretty much BS what the filmmakers tried to do afterwards, i.e., not showing his final "fist." Why hide it from us? We already know he killed a pregnant mom and a kid. What's the big mystery in wondering whether he'd take the next step?

reply

I felt like that situation would have just sucked so bad that I would have ended up volunteering. It seemed like a quick painless death and I would have just wanted it over with.

reply

"It seemed like a quick painless death"
---------------------------------
Just based on the way both the rich guy and the black guy reacted when they got zapped, I don't think it was painless.

reply

Yeah, the killing process seemed vicious but I also thought they were getting tased and so it seemed as though they were dying but really weren't?turned out they were getting killed though.

reply

Not that far unless by sheer luck, I'm not nearly smart enough to figure out the game so quickly like Eric and not likeable or social enough to bond and relate with people, I'll just be like Shawn or the mute guy, although I would certainly play the game and vote like most people.

reply

I'd hope i make it to the end & like Eric I'd kill the pregnant woman & child. I'm more like the long haired hippy guy. I want to live & would try to assemble a team to vote out the girl. But after watching the movie, I'd probably use Eric's strategy.

reply

Not until the end, nor would I want to make it until the end. The whole scenario is a lose-lose situation - even if you survive, you'd have to either commit, or consent to a huge pile of atrocities, something I wouldn't want to live with.
...Or be a child and be lucky that your circle contains merciful people, which is already too late for me .

there's a highway that is curling up like smoke above her shoulder

reply