What did you think?


I have read The Red Tent twelve (yes 12) times!

I just can't get over how different the movie was from the book. Did the screenwriter even read the book? Did Anita Diamont have any input?

Why was it about Dinah & her relationship with her father?

All but a few Biblical truths that are in the book are left out of the movie!

The thing that bothered me the most would have been so easy to do in the movie! Why were Leah's eyes the same color? She couldn't of worn a different color contact in one eye?

reply

I understand what you mean, toodlerue. I know some changes have to happen to speed up the pace for TV. But some changes seem unnecessary.



No two persons ever watch the same movie.

reply

[deleted]

I have heard many great reviews about the book. While I have not yet read it myself to compare it to the movie, I was just not impressed with this mini-series. I was excited to see the previews for it and knew that it was an adaptation of a novel about Dinah as soon as I saw the title, but it just did not quite deliver. Part one was okay. I liked the background of Jacob and how he came to have four wives and how out of their polygamous circumstances they developed sisterhood. For some reason though, part two dragged on. As I watched the film, I could tell that they were trying too hard to modernize the female lead. Dinah walked through life as though she was completely disconnected from her culture and the beliefs of her people as they shaped their identity. It was as though they put Elizabeth Bennett from Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice in the old testament and watched her life unravel while rebelling against what she felt to be oppression and control. Because this agenda was so obvious I was not convinced I should be rooting for her. If anything her mother was my favorite character out of them all.

Not that I would know, but I thought that the author was a mormon (at least that is what I think I read once). That being said the movie had strong feminist messages within the patriarchal society being portrayed and there was a great deal of idol worship. Both of these elements were presented positively, as if to say "Yahweh and his patriarchs are so mean". It was like the women were bonding through their secret rejection against the God of Jacob, a God who favors men. Most bible related films in hollywood have taken this popular anti-religious approach these days, but it is getting old in my opinion. I did not hate it, but it just was not something I would watch again.

reply

The author of the novel, Anita Diamant, is Jewish, not Mormon.

There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.

reply

Oops! You're right. Thanks for that.

reply

It's good to know that the book is different from the mini series. I've been avoiding the book because of the mini series. I might give it a try now.

reply

The book is EXCELLENT!

reply

the book is better than the movie (like usual) but I thought it followed the book pretty well, with some dramatic exagerations for the point in some of it. I thought it was strange how different Joseph & Dinah looked soooo different than all their brothers, I know Joseph had a different mother but Dinah didn't, she wasn't dark in the least bit and bengamin looked way different than Joseph and they had the same mother and father.

reply

As I suspected. I like these kinds of movies (or series), but there's so much agenda going on. "Noah" was totally wrecked. If I see a biblical movie, I want a biblical movie. I don't have to like every aspect of the culture or time, or, since I actually take God seriously, understand every aspect of his ways. But I want primarily a biblical movie that respects the biblical story. Otherwise I'd rather watch the Lord of the Rings or something.

reply