Hamshakals vs Gunday
It will be fun to see who is at the lowest rating: Hamshakals or Gunday.
I haven't seen either of them, but would love to hear some painful experiences from those who have.
Gunday is not as bad to be at such a low rating. The rating of Gunday is primarily because of Bangladeshi audiences not liking the way the movie reconstructed history at will, thus irking the Bangladeshi audiences. If you read the reviews of Gunday in imdb, you will see only people from bangladesh contributed in it.
Gunday is a average 6 rating movie.
As for Humshakals didn't see it.
6 stars? Are you kidding me? It's nothing more than probably 3 stars if I'm feeling generous. That was a *beep* script totally and poor execution with poor dialogues and unnecessary songs.
Why do we fall?
Brother, I agree with your points. It had unnecessary songs and it was 20 minutes too long. But if I just look at the story (though a mish-mash), I will still see that the makers tried to instill some story and sense into this otherwise mundane movie which I didn't find in most of the recent releases (e.g. Grand Masti/Shaadi Ke Side Effects etc). So I gave a generous 6 for their efforts of putting up a story :)
shareGrand Masti was 1 on 10. That's why I gave 3 on 10 to Gunday.
Why do we fall?