MovieChat Forums > Naked and Afraid (2013) Discussion > Alone vs Naked and Afraid - which is tou...

Alone vs Naked and Afraid - which is tougher?

posted 8 years ago by netsez00
6 replies | jump to latest

Which survival experience is more difficult to survive in?

Naked and Afraid
Pros
1. Another person for help with survival tasks
2. Another person for social interaction
3. Camera crew films you
Cons
1. No clothes, less protection against the elements
2. Only allowed one tool

Alone
Pros
1. Clothes, better protection against the elements
2. Allowed 10 tools
Cons
1. No one to help with survival tasks
2. No one for social interaction
3. Must film your actions

[–] danickster 8 years ago

Alone definitely

-------?---------
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=uhyfVEVY_oQ

"I am I am I said I'm not myself. I'm not dead and......

[–] beeger 8 years ago

Alone

[–] Stigger 8 years ago

Naked and Afraid
Pros
1. Another person for help with survival tasks
2. Another person for social interaction
3. Camera crew films you

You failed to include how the production crew often help the participants (contrary to what the show tells us to believe).

[–] DaveBowman2001 7 years ago

Spend a night naked in the pouring rain at 47F and you might change your mind. Alone looks way easier. Shoes/clothes/tools make life so much easier. No psycho to argue with either.

[–] znapper 7 years ago

Alone and naked would be way easier than clothed and afraid.

Some of these women are complete nutcases and they not only sap the energy of the men, the also demand the man to build crap and hunt extra food as well, sapping both physical and mental strength.

A few of the women have pulled their weight as well (being hampered by a lazy, grumpy, bossy man), but they are few and far between.

Alone and naked would simply require the right mindset to begin with, few to none of the participants in the past seasons have had that.

Naked and afraid (of your partner) must be hell.

[–] aavfreak (2859) 3 years ago

I would rather attempt Alone than Naked and Afraid. Due to the lack of tools and resources, Naked and Afraid is more like "endure and not die" than a survival show. Alone allows for more potential to actually use skills and improve your own situation.