MovieChat Forums > Boy Meets Girl (2015) Discussion > Is it dubbed?

Is it dubbed?

posted 8 years ago by Sam-953-169285
9 replies | jump to latest

I hope no one minds me asking if Ricky's voice is dubbed. Is it Michelle Hendley's real voice? Michelle Hendley is so feminine that it is difficult to believe it is her talking.

If this movie is realistic then I apologize for doubting it. Would a transgender person that has developed so much into such a feminine woman still have such a deep voice?

Again, does Michelle Hendley really have such a deep voice?

Update: I guess it is her real voice, watch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I18AHsV1DXM

If anyone chooses to comment on me saying "her", note that the IMDB says "actress". So I assume "her" is proper.

[–] Splash_Woman 8 years ago

Unfortunately, once a voice has dropped it's dropped. Lots of things can be changed through treatment with estrogen; however, the voice isn't one of them. Michelle and other trans women who've experienced a male puberty have to train their voices in order to sound typically feminine. Surgery is, in some cases, needed or desired in order for the trans woman to comfortably hit the right pitch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b-V4wDJbtJk - a before and after video of voice surgery, if you're curious.

[–] Sam-953-169285 8 years ago

You know, that does not answer my question. I asked if the movie was dubbed or it is the actresses' real voice. The YouTube video probably answers my question but note that nothing else in the reply does.

I did find a relevant YouTube video after I posted my question. So I do know now that it was really her voice and it was even her seen naked getting out of the water (no special affects or such) and it was even her real masculinity flopping around in that scene.

Michelle is quite amazing but that is a different subject.

[–] Splash_Woman 8 years ago

I understood your post fine, and I was answering a question you asked.

You asked, "Would a transgender person that has developed so much into such a feminine woman still have such a deep voice?" I gave you the answer and explained why things are that way.

[–] Sam-953-169285 8 years ago

The subject is "Is it dubbed?". That is a question. My first paragraph begins with:

I hope no one minds me asking if Ricky's voice is dubbed. Is it Michelle Hendley's real voice?

My third paragraph was:

Again, does Michelle Hendley really have such a deep voice?

You never answered any of those questions. You implied that it is not dubbed but you sure did not say so explicitly.

I apologize for being picky but many people have problems communicating. It would help for people to be clear.

[–] cdcarte1 8 years ago

Your second paragraph was

Would a transgender person that has developed so much into such a feminine woman still have such a deep voice?

So they did, in fact, answer one of your questions. So, maybe don't be rude and call their response irrelevant. Sure, some people have problems communicating, but some people also have problems with manners. You, apparently, have problems with both.

[–] Sam-953-169285 8 years ago

No one in this discussion was personally critical to the extent you are being here. Some people have problems with being emotionally hurtful whenever they see the opportunity to.

[–] skrodlada 8 years ago

I think you miss the point that Michelle is transgender in real life meaning her voice dropped before her change. So no it is not dubbed.

[–] catrina604 7 years ago

Your question was answered in this thread.

Hugs

[–] Sam-953-169285 7 years ago

And the Sun rose this morning. Your post and this one are equally superfluous.

Perhaps you don't understand what "update" means.