MovieChat Forums > Mandariinid (2015) Discussion > Wow. Ida better be freakin' fantastic

Wow. Ida better be freakin' fantastic


This film absolutely blew me away. What an emotional powerhouse. It was so powerful and moving on so many levels. This is one of the best films I've seen in a while. What a pity it was not able to grab the Oscar. I hope Ida is just as wonderful, or else this feel was majorly robbed!

reply

Ida was really good, but Tangerines is better in my opinion.

reply

The Foreign Film category this year was packed - MUCH better than the actual Best Picture nominee list IMHOP.

TANGERINES, LEVIATHAN and IDA are three of the best movies of any kind I have seen in the last 12 months. TIMBUKTU is very good, and WILD TALES, while inconsistent, is a decent fun ride.

My ranking would be:

1. IDA
2. LEVIATHAN
3. TANGERINES
4. TIMBUKTU
5. WILD TALES

But, I could easily live with a re-arrangement of the the top 3 depending on personal preference. I just found IDA to be a piece of masterful mesmerizing simplicity, but your mileage may vary.

reply

1. TANGERINES
2. LEVIATHAN
3. WILD TALES
4. IDA
5. TIMBUKTU

this would be my ranking. Ida was visually stunning but thats it.

reply

Watched both, and Tangerines is better. Ida won because holocaust topics always sell well.

reply

WILD TALES: 7/10
TANGERINES: 8/10
IDA; LEVIATHAN: Worst good movie

reply