Read the book


interesting that they are making this into a movie. I enjoyed the book, but many thought it was dry

reply

me too i already read the book. nice book and i think this will be a good book if they give their best in acting

reply

I'm just about finished reading the book; I stumbled across the IMDB page looking for some general reviews of it.

It IS pretty dry! It reads like a self-help book for salesmen, but with some sex and violence thrown in. Sort of like Eliyahu Goldratt's "The Goal," but with some nipple-sucking.

Maybe if I keep waiting (sort of like Alan has to keep waiting, and waiting, and waiting for the king to show up), the point of the book will show up, too!

reply

[deleted]

The problem is that the main character, Alan Clay (Tom Hanks) isn't very interesting. He's not a "hero." He's not even an "anti-hero." He's a schlub, a mensch. He's an average, directionless guy. A few interesting adventures befall him, and he screws most of them up in wholly UNspectacular ways!

I could see this being an INDIE film, nothing more.

(BTW, I just finished the book. Eh. Bleh. I'll borrow the DVD from the library a few months after it comes out)

reply

http://judaism.about.com/od/glossary/g/whatisamensch.htm A mensch is a responsible
upright person,someone other look-up to.We Americans would say a person of integrity.Not a sclub at all,SSYWAK-2.

reply

You're right, the two are not the same. I would still say shlub, not mensch, though.

reply

based on just the subject line, how do we ascertain whether you meant "red" the book or "reed" the book? 

reply

That's the whole point. He's an average, unremarkable guy trying to be remarkable. It seems you missed the whole point of the book. Maybe Eggers is over your head.

reply

So I take it you didn't enjoy "Death of a Salesman" either. 😀

reply

I enjoyed Death of a Salesman. But it had to do with family dynamics, not just one guy.

So, what does this story have over and above Salesman?

reply

I enjoyed the book as well, but I'm a fan of David Eggers. I enjoy all his books. I can't imagine someone thinking it was "dry," except that it took place in the desert. (Sorry. Couldn't resist.) It wasn't "in your face" and had some subtlety to it that some readers might miss, so it may not be for everyone. I'm looking forward to seeing the movie.

reply

what are some other books similar to this?

reply