a masterpiece


it has to be on the imdb top 250

reply

Definitely

reply

I agree - it has it all.

reply

I don't know that I'd call it a masterpiece, which I think is a very overused term, but I did find it gripping and really enjoyed watching it. The '70s setting and style of cinematography were very well done. Dujardin and Lellouche both played their parts convincingly.

reply

Agreed - not a masterpiece even of its genre. But certainly very good. And good use of soundtrack as well

reply

It was good, but too long and too slow. Of course not a masterpiece, just good.

reply

I enjoyed the film but couldn't help feeling it's sort of been done all before in various elements. Well acted and enjoyed the 70's cinematography as another reviewer remarked. Saying that it's better than the majority of the Hollywood garbage that comes out now days.

reply

Im with bronco tim. Its a very good movie but NOT the mindblowing masterpiece everyone thinks it is. Overexposed washed out cinematography, too loosely edited ( needs to be shorter).

yeah its a lot smarter than juvenile c--p like " fast and furious part __________" but those flicks, as dumb as they are- move move and move! This falls short of other gangster classics like Goodfellas or..... can I say it , "the French Connection"


The two lead actors look too much alike, confusing me a lot.
And I didnt really feel emotionally engaged with either character until the last quarter of the film.

reply

I didnt really feel emotionally engaged with either character until the last quarter of the film.
The film kept quite distant from its characters. We 'learn' most about Pierre Michel but no one else. Perhaps in France these real life events and its people are familiar enough. The character I engaged with immediately was Bimbo! He made me laugh but like many appeared briefly. My favourite character was Crazy Horse but we learn next to nothing about him.
A bird sings and the mountain's silence deepens.

reply

It's a very good film but not a masterpiece.

A bird sings and the mountain's silence deepens.

reply

For me it was a 10.

I like Armageddon. A lot.

reply

Hardly a masterpiece. Watch Melville films - those are the masterpieces. Also, Heat is much better than this.

reply