MovieChat Forums > The 7.39 (2014) Discussion > Was Ryan really the father?

Was Ryan really the father?


I suspected that it was carl.

reply

I agree it was probably Carl,but from the closing scene,are we to assume that Sally had split from Ryan?
But what a wonderful two-parter.Hardly an original idea,but it didn't matter.The script was terrific and the performances by all the actors was absolutely superb.

reply

Of course we are to "assume" Sally split from Ryan. It was completely obvious during the scene when he was busy "forgiving" her that it was over, as far as she was concerned, it was clear from the expression on her face. Yes, clearly, she has had her child and has a new life with a new man.

And why would Carl "probably" be the father? Sally and Carl both said they used "protection" when they had sex, something she and Ryan didn't do. So "probably" Ryan was the father, as Sally said.

reply

OK,OK Cleverdick.No need to take that tone.

reply

I think you will find it was Ryan who was the cleverdick imo

reply

bahahah cleverdick, LOL that made my day

reply

Definitely Ryan. Simple maths - she was 8 weeks pregnant (she mentions she has 32 weeks to go) and had only been seeing Carl for a month.

reply