Ages


I wonder how many people like me find many of these American Girl movies somewhat spoiled by using actors and actresses who are much older than their characters. I mean Sidney Fulmer is an excellent young actress but is 4 years older than her character, she is completely unbelievable as a nine year old, even her voice sounds older. The same also applied to the Molly film, she celebrated her tenth birthday but was played by a 13 year old. I'm sure there are many talented 9 and 10 year old actors and actresses out there who could play the roles just as well. I mean Samantha and Kit were both played by actresses who were of the right age so why not the rest?

reply

Sidney was great, really. The huge, awful casting problem was with the girl who played her best friend; seriously?? No way in Hades that girl's not in the double digits.

reply

I thought Sidney and the other girls all did a great job. There have been a lot of movies where actors played much younger than they were. The girls ages didn't make a difference to me. They were all adorable.

reply