MovieChat Forums > Bird Box (2018) Discussion > So how is A Quiet Place better then?

So how is A Quiet Place better then?


One whole number up on Bird Box imdb rating 6.6 & 7.6 respectively. I don't get I felt not one slither of fear whilst watching A Quiet Place whilst Bird Box gave me chills and was very unsettling at points especially moments near the begining with people trying to off themselves in public.

reply

If you still believe imdb ratings are representative at all despite "utter shit" or "worth a watch", you haven't been paying attention.

reply

Bird Box was very good for about half the movie. Then, almost as if a switch was flipped, it become much less interesting and more tiresome to watch.

A Quiet Place, while possibly not being as good as Bird Box when Bird Box was at its very best, was an overall more even film and more enjoyable as a whole.

reply

Who said it was better? IMDb ratings don't mean squat.

Both movies are pretty decent. Both have good ideas but are just not executed so great.

reply