I presume you have finally abandoned your earlier allegations that Cris was involved with the jacket now that video evidence confirms what we were trying to tell you?
I presume you have finally abandoned your earlier claim that Cris was didn't tell Giles to limbo now that video evidence confirms what I've been trying to tell you.
I fail to see how that is a tip of any significance.
The reason for Cris telling Giles to limbo is so that Giles would take off his jacket. And in the summary, the killer said that Geno stole Giles' cell phone after Giles took off his jacket to do the limbo, which Cris told him to do.
Like I've been trying to explain to you, a tip doesn't mean that everything is spelled out for them. A tip could just be a detail that they might not think is important at the moment, but given other clues that they find out later, the detail that they got from the tip could help them put all the clues together.
We do the same thing. When we watch the final episode and they reveal some clues from earlier episodes, some of those clues we overlooked and didn't think were important when those episodes originally aired.
For example, when Don, Melina, and Cris were examining the crime scene in the 1st episode, Don used terms that cops normally used. Melina called Don "the ex-cop". Don said "I'm not a cop". Cris said her dad was a cop. Now that by itself didn't raise any suspicions at that time.
But later, Cris said she knew about horses after Ulysses' murder and said she knew about guns after Geno's murder. Now suddenly Cris' statement in the 1st episode about her dad being a cop has some significance.
Similarly for Cris:
1. The producers tell Cris to tell Giles to limbo so Giles would take off his jacket.
By itself, that detail might not seem to be important to Cris at that time.
But later on:
2. Giles' tells Cris and Melina to go to the morgue themselves because he seems to have lost his cell phone.
3. In the morgue, Cris and Melina find Giles' cell phone in Geno's pants when Giles calls his cell phone.
4. Lindsey basically tells Kam and Cris that the killer left a note for Geno to steal Giles' cell phone.
So the question is when and how did Geno have the opportunity to steal Giles' cell phone. Well, now that Cris knows #2, #3, and #4, suddenly #1 is no longer a trivial detail. #1 is now the "insider" tip that allows Cris to tie it all together and deduce that Geno stole Giles' cell phone when Giles took off his jacket after Cris told him to limbo, similar to how Melina was able to deduce from other clues that Ronnie wrote a letter in the library and drank some tea.
all the cast is in on the limbo scene and have parts to play.
Think about it.
None of the other cast told Giles to limbo. Only Cris. There were 6 people there. If the producers were just giving a directorial note, as you claim, they could've told any of the 6 to tell Giles to limbo. But they only told Cris, their paid employee, to tell Giles to limbo.
Why only Cris, their paid employee? Think about that.
the producer didn't really like Kam or want him to win.
You're alleging that the producer gave the most oblique tip with the least usefulness to someone who might indirectly leak it to a player he's averse to helping and who already witnessed the event first hand anyway?
First, Their intention wasn't to give the "insider" tip to Kam to help him win. Their intention was to give the "insider" tip to Cris, their paid employee, to help her. They probably expected that Cris would give that information to Kam and Lindsey, but it was a chance they had to take to help their paid employee.
Also, even if it seemed that Zuiker didn't like Kam, it seemed that Zuiker did like Lindsey. And there was no guarantee that Kam would beat out Lindsey in the final.
Second, like I said, we've been assuming all along that the producers didn't give any "insider" tips to Cris. But now we know that the producers did tip off Cris on an element of Geno's murder. So what other "insider" tips did the producers give to Cris (and then Cris give to Kam and Lindsey) on some of the other murders that weren't as "oblique" as you claim this "insider" tip was?
We know that Cris, the producers' paid employee, was the only 1 of 6 that was told by the producers to tell Giles to limbo. Cris, the producers' paid employee, was also the first 1 of 8 to find the floorboard with the 2 finishing nails when her "team" was down 3 vs 5.
Hmmm. Was that just a coincidence? Or was that the result of the producers giving "insider" tips to Cris (which Cris then gave to Kam and Lindsey, helping them make it to the finals)?
But the producers wouldn't do that because it's a Federal offense, right? And Wall Street brokers would never commit insider trading because that's also a Federal offense, right?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fOwfRyd9avY
reply
share