MovieChat Forums > 7-beon-bang-ui seon-mul (2013) Discussion > I want to give this 9 actually but...

I want to give this 9 actually but...

posted 11 years ago by fluffset
13 replies | jump to latest

I give it 10, why? Bcoz I thought this movie is very very good but its so weird when all those smart people absolutely ignore his papa's condition, its so obvious and will not happen but this is the first movie I ever saw that can make me crying a lot even I'm a man. Never crying like hell before! Are you crying too? A lot?

[–] leon_and_mathilda 11 years ago

ya, Cried like a baby.

[–] hunterexy 11 years ago

almost cried,but the logic of story's suck,I held back the tears

[–] fluffset 11 years ago

yeah, the story is not too logic but its really strong!

[–] elicious80 11 years ago

Actually I think police mistreatment and coercion of mentally disabled suspects is a problem in Korea. Just watch "Mother (2009)" to see police again taking advantage of a mentally handicapped man to make him confess to a murder. So this aspect of the movie does not seem unbelievable at all.

Now the parts that are a bit unbelievable is the sneaking in and out of the girl, building the hot air balloon in prison, and the hot air balloon escape scene. But the movie IS a comedy after all, so it's ok to go a bit over-the-top for comedic value. I think most comedies are guilty of this.

[–] marqik 10 years ago

"Mother" is a good example, but the police really take advantage in "Memories of Murder".

[–] skyblazeeterno 10 years ago

yeah in Memories Of Murder it was quite sickening

[–] chilone 9 years ago

Actually I think police mistreatment and coercion of mentally disabled suspects is a problem in Korea. Just watch "Mother (2009)" to see police again taking advantage of a mentally handicapped man to make him confess to a murder. So this aspect of the movie does not seem unbelievable at all.

Same thing in Memories Of Murder.

I don't love her.. She kicked me in the face!!

[–] cosan 11 years ago

i gave it a 9 while still crying, and then went back and gave it a perfect 10. reminded me of grave of the fireflies... i couldn't breath through my nose then, and now i cant.

[–] duy_le76 11 years ago

I cannot hesitate to give this perfect 10, heart-breaking movie like Mother (2009). Korean is one of the best drama film-producers in the world.

[–] Uberlim 10 years ago

bof both were subpar imho, worth a viewing tho

[–] marqik 10 years ago

I think "Mother" was a better film, but this was above par in my opinion. The prisoners were a little too goofy, and the hot air balloon subplot was a bit of a stretch for me. The acting by the father and daughter was great.

[–] Nokitron 10 years ago

I couldn't make it to the end of movie. I died of bored already.

The spook never ends.

[–] constance_c888 9 years ago

I made it! Skipping some part though. I like the movie but it's too unrealistic. It's meant to be fun but the part that he seems 'to know' he's going to die soon or death penalty doesn't make sense. Isn't he mentally challenged?

Ich habe eine Hassliebe mit Deutsch.